Six lessons on how to make affordable housing funding work across Australia

  • Written by Laurence Troy, Research Fellow, City Futures Research Centre, UNSW
Six lessons on how to make affordable housing funding work across Australia

A suitable construction funding model is the critical missing ingredient needed to deliver more affordable housing in Australia. Aside from short-lived programs under the Rudd government, we have seen decades of inconsistent and fragmented policies loosely directed at increasing affordable housing. These have failed to generate anything like enough new supply to meet outstanding needs.

Our latest research looked at recently built, larger-scale affordable housing projects in contrasting markets across Australia. We examined each scheme’s cost, funding sources and outcomes. We then developed a housing needs-driven model for understanding the financial and funding requirements to develop affordable housing in the diverse local conditions across the country.

Read more: Australia needs to reboot affordable housing funding, not scrap it

Up to now, the key stumbling block has been the “funding gap” between revenue from rents paid by low-income tenants and the cost of developing and maintaining good-quality housing. The Commonwealth Treasury acknowledged this problem last year. And the problem is greatest in the urban areas where affordable housing is most needed.

What does the new model tell us?

The Affordable Housing Assessment Tool (AHAT) enables the user to calculate cost-effective ways to fund affordable housing to meet specified needs in different markets. It’s a flexible interactive spreadsheet model with an innovative feature: it enables users to embed housing needs as the driver of project and policy, rather than project financial feasibility driving who can be housed.

Affordable housing developments have recently been relatively sparse. However, our research highlighted the varied and bespoke funding arrangements being used.

Despite this variety, too often project outcomes are driven purely by funding opportunities and constraints, rather than by defined housing needs. One notable constraint is the fragmented nature of affordable housing subsidy frameworks both within and across jurisdictions.

Our case study projects generated a diversity of housing outcomes. This can be seen as an unintended positive of the bespoke nature of affordable housing provision as a result of the need to “stitch together” gap funding from multiple sources on a project-by-project basis.

Equally though, the lack of policy coherence and fit-for-purpose funding added cost and complexity to the development process. By implication, this leads to a less-than-optimal outcome for public investment. Despite providers’ best efforts, current approaches are not the most efficient way to deliver much-needed affordable housing.

Read more: Affordable housing, finger-pointing politics and possible policy solutions

What are the lessons from this research?

We applied the model to typical housing development scenarios in inner and outer metropolitan areas and regions. By doing so, we identified six key lessons for funding and financing affordable housing delivery.

1) Government help with access to land is central to affordable housing development and enhances long-term project viability.

Especially in high-pressure urban markets, not-for-profit housing developers cannot compete with the private sector for development sites. High land costs, particularly in inner cities where affordable housing demand is most extreme, can render financial viability near impossible. Having access to sites and lower-cost land were two of the most important components of feasible projects.

2) Government equity investment offers considerable potential for delivering feasible projects and net benefit to government.

How governments treat the valuation of public land with potential for affordable housing development must be reviewed. Conventionally, even where affordable housing is the intended use, governments typically insist on a land sale price based on “highest and best use”.

It would be preferable in such cases to treat the below-market value assigned to public land as a transparent subsidy input. This would mean the sale price reflects the housing needs that the development seeks to meet. That is, the land value should be priced as an affordable housing development for a specific needs cohort.

By retaining an equity stake, government could account for its input as an investment that will increase in value over time as land values appreciate.

3) Reducing up-front debt load and lowering finance costs are critical to long-term project viability.

Debt funding imposes a large cost burden over a project’s lifetime. This is ultimately paid down through tenant rents. Reducing both the cost and scale of private financing can have a significant impact on project viability.

The analysis reinforces the rationale for the Australian government’s “bond aggregator” facility for reducing financing costs for affordable housing projects. But this must come in tandem with other measures to reduce up-front debt.

Read more: Government guarantee opens investment highway to affordable housing

4) Delivery across the range of housing needs helps to meet overall social and tenure mix objectives. This also can help improve project viability through cross-subsidy.

Mixing tenure and tenant profiles can enable affordable housing providers to produce more diverse housing that meets the full range of needs.

Cross-subsidy opportunities arising from mixed-tenure and mixed-use developments can also enhance project feasibility. By improving a provider’s financial position, this helps advance their long-term goal of adding to the stock of affordable housing. And, by providing welcome flexibility, this enables organisations to better manage development risk across different markets and cycles.

5) The financial benefit of planning bonuses is limited

Inclusionary zoning mechanisms impose affordable housing obligations on developers through the planning system. This approach potentially offers a means of securing affordable housing development sites in larger urban renewal or master-planned areas.

However, our research demonstrated that planning bonuses allowing increased dwelling numbers in return for more affordable housing have little beneficial impact on project viability. This is because the additional dwellings allowed generate additional land and/or construction costs but no matching capacity to service a larger debt.

However, planning bonuses can be useful as part of a cross-subsidy approach. In this case, they may support project viability, without necessarily resulting in any additional affordable dwellings.

6) Increasing the scale of not-for-profit provision offers financial benefits that help ensure the long-term delivery of affordable housing.

Our analysis supports the case for targeting public subsidy to not-for-profit developers (government or non-government) to maximise long-term social benefit. Investing in permanently affordable housing ensures the social dividend of affordable housing can be continued into the future.

Comparable subsidies are not preserved when allocated to private owners. They will seek to trade out at some stage, capitalising the subsidy into privatised gain.

The results of our case study analyses and modelling highlight the need to develop comprehensive funding and subsidy arrangements that account for different costs in different locations. These arrangements also must be integrated nationally to support affordable housing delivery at scale.

This study reiterates the common finding of research over the last decade: both Commonwealth and state/territory governments need to develop a coherent and long-term policy framework to provide housing across the full spectrum of need.

Authors: Laurence Troy, Research Fellow, City Futures Research Centre, UNSW

Read more http://theconversation.com/six-lessons-on-how-to-make-affordable-housing-funding-work-across-australia-91072

Australia Today

Strengthening ties between Australia and the USA

Malcolm Turnbull

The alliance between Australia and the United States has been broadened and deepened by my visit to Washington D.C.   In a reflection of the ongoing importance of the relationship, I held a successful meeting with President Donald J. Trump in the Oval Office at the White House.   Our fourth me...

Read more

Cochlear Implant Day this Sunday

Scott Tucker

 GIVING THE GIFT OF SOUND TO INDONESIANS     Minister for Trade and Industry, Niall Blair this week met with cochlear implant recip...

Read more

Nick Xenophon announces energy co-op to lower SA power bills

Erin Clare

An exciting plan to lower power prices using the co-operative model of community electricity trusts has been announced by SA BEST leader Nick Xenophon.   “The co-operative model has an internationally proven track record for delivering services,” said Business Council of Cooperatives and Mutuals...

Read more

Jodie & Soda rallied the community to make Alex the 'best firefighter ever'

Tina Liptai

  Adelaide has a new pint-size hero after Mix 102.3's Jodie & Soda rallied the community to make Alex the 'best firefighter ever'     ...

Read more

Barnaby Joyce: the story of an unlikely rise and a self-inflicted fall

Michelle Grattan, Professorial Fellow, University of Canberra

Joyce's departure to the backbench obviously brings immediate relief for the government and the Nationals. What it will mean beyond that is more difficult to predict.AAP/Marlon DaltonIn the end, the tough man crumpled. For a fortnight Barnaby Joyce had resembled someone out in the snow who’d b...

Read more

Top 10 Deadliest Building Fires in Australia

Geordie Killen

A few months from now, we're going to celebrate Fire Prevention Week and one of the best ways to understand the dangers of fire is to remember worst fire incidents in Australia. By reading the harrowing stories of these fire disasters, people will be more aware of how dangerous fires can be. It wi...

Read more

Arming teachers will only make US school shootings worse

Rick Sarre, Adjunct Professor of Law and Criminal Justice, University of South Australia

US President Donald Trump talks to high school students about safety on campus following the shooting deaths of 17 people at a Florida school.Reuters/Jonathan ErnstOn February 14, in Parkland, Florida, 17 teachers and students were shot dead at their school by an estranged student armed with a high-...

Read more

Holidays & Travel

Places That Will Make You Want to Visit Indonesia This Year

Royalty, culture and history coalesce in Yogyakarta     Seasoned travellers wanting more than boutique shopping, hip bars and cutting edge restaurants are invited to try a new Indonesian island or include one...

STA Travel: MASSIVE THREE DAY NEW ZEALAND SALE

NEW ZEALAND FLASH SALE!!!!    For the next THREE DAYS ONLY, STA Travel is having massive flight and Campervan hire sales for New Zealand!!    Fly one way for $129, and RETURN FOR $275!! Campervans start from $47 a day!    If...

MANTRA HOTELS LAUNCHES BIGGEST EVER GLOBAL SALE

Mantra Hotels is set to launch its biggest ever Global Sale with massive savings on more than 130 Mantra, Peppers, BreakFree and Art Series Hotels, booked between 13 - 21...

Bangkok's Winter Festival "Love and Warmth at Winter's End"

His Majesty King Maha Vajiralongkorn Bodindradebayavarangkun has graciously initiated the organisation of a winter festival under the theme 'Un Ai Rak Khlai Khwam Nao' (Love and Warmth at Winter's End)...

Give Your Valentine a Villa in Mykonos

Need a Last-Minute Valentine’s Day Gift?  For $66 Give Your Valentine a Villa in MykonosThis Valentine’s Day, if you are still debating on a meaningful gift for your loved one...

The Nam Hai Launches AntiGravityYoga and Unveils New Serenity Structure

Hoi An, Vietnam – Four Seasons Resort The Nam Hai, Hoi An is elevating its wellbeing offering with a new yoga pavilion and introduction of AntiGravity® Yoga, a dynamic 'flying' yoga...

Rydges South Bank rolls out the MAGIC CARPET to welcome Aladdin to Brisbane!

Rydges South Bank is rolling out their very own magic carpet to welcome the blockbuster stage show Disney’s Aladdin – The Musical to Brisbane, announcing an exclusive stay, taste and...

New cellar doors across Tasmania

New Cellar Door at Clover Hill Drawing inspiration from the form of a clover leaf, the new Clover Hill cellar door ( sits on the edge of the valley...

Club Med helps Aussies hack their holidays

This month, Club Med is helping Australians make the most of their annual leave and save more on the holidays of their dreams, by offering their best price all year...

Fashion & Beauty

The Most Stylish Women of All Time and How to Be Like Them

The mark of style is uniqueness. It’s not just in following the trends; it’s in being creative enough to set new ones in place. It’s about natural allure that draws...

Australian size-inclusive activewear label Active Truth

Mums and daughters #twinning in new activewear range that encourages healthy body image in women and girls Mums and daughters #twinning in new activewear range that encourages healthy body image im...

Bras N Things Heat Up The Night campaign

Inspired by hot summer nights and dazzling neon city lights, Bras N Things’ new Heat Up The Night campaign showcases stunning fashion lingerie, decadent embroidered lace and bold caging details.   Featuring...

Fashion Moment Holiday: Restyle Your Wardrobe and Enjoy Exclusive Shopping Privileges at Four Seasons

Adjacent to the prestigious IFC mall, Four Seasons Hotel Hong Kong has always been the venue of choice for the glam and glitterati to flaunt their fashion statements. Housing five...

Staying Fashionable on the Beach this Summer

Whether you’re travelling alone, with your partner for the first time or on a relaxing trip with your whole family or friend group, looking great while you’re on the beach...

Santamaria Shirt Makers

Traditional shirt-making for the modern era How the second generation of a traditional shirt maker is transforming the family business for the digital age From Madrid to London and now the world...

HEALTH

Cinzia Cozzolinos shares her 7 Day Feb-Fast Detox

Nutritionist and Founder of Nutrition Darling and Smoothie Bombs shares her 7 Day Feb-Fast Detox.  Cinzia Cozzolinos Tips are below and her 7 Day Plant Based Eating Plan is...

Malcolm Turnbull - Ground-breaking flu vaccines to protect millions of Aussies

The Turnbull Government will provide two new ground-breaking flu vaccines to over three million Australians aged 65 years and over - free of charge. This is a direct response to last...

Alcovit

Here we go a "new hangover cure", sure thing whatever.   Alcovit Australia states from the start it is NOT a Hangover Cure, it is NOT something that allows you to drink...

"Career mums" vs "home makers"

Mums today are adjusted into many different scenarios; whether you have a stay at home business, working only a couple of days a week whilst your children are with carers...

Seasonal health retreat in a box

A seasonal reminder to slow down can help manage anxiety and stress in Australian women. It’s back to work and back to the daily grind. Well-being expert, Holistic Nutritionist and Personal...

Surviving A Divorce

Breakups are tough at the best of times. When you’ve been married for some time, have a family, and find that your relationship has broken down beyond repair, the process...

LIFE STYLE

Get green with your gardening needs

Do you consider yourself a particularly green-fingered gardener who has a real love and passion for flowers and other shrubbery? If your answer to this questions is yes, then you...

5 Most Common Household Emergencies and How to Fix Them

If you have a large and old house, there’s a pretty big chance that there are going to be some emergencies every now and then. It’s important to maintain the...

How to Life Plan with Your Children’s Future in Mind

For most people, a big part of their life plan involves kids. Children are one of life’s great joys, but also one of life’s great financial burdens. The good news...

8 Easy Tips for Keeping Your Home Healthy and Clean

Although we see our homes as our safe havens, they aren’t actually as safe as we may think. In fact, there are probably numerous hidden toxins and allergens that we...

Cleaning Tips for Your Living Space in Australia

We all know that cleaning our home is extremely important; however, it seems that not all Aussies take this seriously and make some crucial mistakes when it comes to the...

Sydney Bayside Home Retreat for any family

Amid the leafy based greenery of The Sydney Suburb Putney resides a timeless new feature home setting to the modern 2018 family unit. The conjunction of bayside living, ambiance, tranquility...

FOOD & DINING

Tips for Drinking Wine around the World

Compromises are for relationships, not wine. – Sir Robert Scott Caywood Do you know how eating food from all over the world is in fact a unique way of traveling around...

Introducing Champagne lovers to, Emperor, Australia’s home of Champagne

Every bottle of Champagne ordered from Emperor is beautifully packaged in custom Emperor gift boxes or wrapping paper. Emperor houses the most extensive collection of champagne in Australia.   Kyla says:...

Hot Stuff: the strategically engineered reusable coffee cup combating Australia¹s landfill epidemic

As Australia’s caffeine addiction continues to soar, environmentalists warn that disposable coffee cups are fast on their way to becoming a major pollution hazard. According to the ABC (2016), coffee cups...

Get saucy this Valentine's Day with Lillie's Q

Whether you’re spending Valentine’s Day with a special partner or celebrating love with your friends, why not treat them (and yourself) to something a little different this year. Get your taste...

Winter Food and Wellness a Winning Combination for Aussies Travelling to Japan

Increased flight options, striking natural scenery, fascinating culture, world-famous onsens and delicious food: there are many reasons why the Australian love affair with Japan seems to be a never ending...

Move over avocado toast. This millennial has created healthy bake mixes

Back to work and school healthy snacks made with real ingredients. 29 year old Genevieve Le Hunt grabbed a gap in the baking mix market. Genevieve created Bake Mixes, organic, vegan...