FactCheck Q A: are 'almost 60%' of small business owners paid '$50,000 or less'?

  • Written by Janine Dixon, Economist at Centre of Policy Studies, Victoria University

The Conversation fact-checks claims made on Q&A, broadcast Mondays on the ABC at 9.35pm. Thank you to everyone who sent us quotes for checking via Twitter using hashtags #FactCheck and #QandA, on Facebook or by email.

Excerpt from Q&A, February 5, 2018.

Almost 60% of small business owners in this country are paid $50,000 or less.

– Australian Chamber of Commerce and Industry chief executive James Pearson, speaking on Q&A, February 5, 2018

The Turnbull government is seeking parliamentary support to cut the company tax rate to 25% over the coming decade, arguing that cutting the rate will increase business investment, drive jobs growth and lift wages in Australia.

During an episode of Q&A, Australian Chamber of Commerce and Industry chief executive James Pearson said small business owners would benefit from a company tax cut in Australia. He said it would “help them be profitable”, allowing them to grow their businesses, employ more people and pay those workers more.

Pearson said “almost 60% of small business owners in this country are paid $50,000 or less”.

Is that right?

FactCheck Q A: are 'almost 60%' of small business owners paid '$50,000 or less'? Checking the source When asked for sources and comment to support James Pearson’s statement, a spokesperson for the Australian Chamber of Commerce and Industry provided The Conversation with the following graph. It draws on unpublished Australian Taxation Office data and relates to the 2014-15 income year: FactCheck Q A: are 'almost 60%' of small business owners paid '$50,000 or less'? Chart from the Australian Small Business and Family Enterprise Ombudsman using unpublished Australia Taxation Office data for the 2014-15 financial year. The data relate to individuals with a non-zero amount at any of the following labels on their 2014-15 tax return: distribution from a partnership or trusts (primary production or non-primary production) and/or net income or loss from business (primary production or non-primary production). The figures were produced to approximate the distribution of small business owners. The spokesperson said: We combined the data for those earning less than $25,000 and those earning $25,000 to $50,000, to come up with the under $50,000 assessment of 58.1% earning less than $50,000. The spokesperson added “we understand the percentages we raised publicly are percentages of all business owners” – as opposed to small business owners. However: We don’t think it makes much of a difference. The overwhelming majority of Australian businesses are clearly small and medium-sized enterprises, and the majority of business owners are small business owners. Verdict James Pearson’s statement that “almost 60% of small business owners in this country are paid $50,000 or less” is in the ballpark. Based on Australia Taxation Office data from the 2014-15 financial year and Census 2016 data, it’s reasonable to say that between 50% to 60% of small business owners or managers earned less than $50,000 in those years. However, Pearson used this information in the context of company tax rate cuts, arguing that small business owners “want a tax cut that will help them be profitable”. In reality, due to the way Australia’s tax system works, it’s the small business owner’s personal income tax rate that is more relevant for the profitability of their business. Calculating small business owner salaries There’s more than one definition for ‘small business’ in Australia, and there’s no perfect data set against which to test Pearson’s statement. But we can assess the Australian Taxation Office data Pearson’s office provided, and we can also look at Census 2016 data. Pearson’s spokesperson provided The Conversation with a graph based on unpublished Australian Taxation Office data for the 2014-15 financial year. The Conversation verified the information in the graph with the Australian Taxation Office. The graph shows that in 2014-15, 58.1% of the business owners listed earned less than $50,000. But the data aren’t specific to small business owners, and don’t include taxable income people received through companies – only through partnerships, trusts or as sole traders. A spokesperson for the Australian Taxation Office told The Conversation the “figures were produced to approximate the distribution of small business owners”. Now let’s look at Census 2016 data. According to the Australian Securities and Investments Commission, “many regulators have informally adopted the definition of ‘small business’ used by the Australian Bureau of Statistics” – which is a business that employs fewer than 20 people. If we look at Census 2016 data using that measure, then we see that 50% of small business owners were paid less than $1,000 per week in 2016 – or $52,000 per year or less. FactCheck Q A: are 'almost 60%' of small business owners paid '$50,000 or less'? Putting Pearson’s statement in context In making his statement, Pearson described the financial struggles facing some small business owners. Pearson said these people “want a tax cut, they want a tax cut that will help them be profitable”. They’ll employ more people, they’ll offer longer hours, more people will have jobs, more people will be paid more. That’s how it works. Pearson added that when small business owners “see more productivity in their workforce, they can take the risk and grow their business”. But the reality is, when an Australian resident is trying to decide whether to invest in their small business, it’s their personal income tax rate, not the company tax rate, that really matters. Why? Because company tax paid by Australian businesses on income earned in Australia acts as a ‘pre-payment’ of personal income tax when that income is distributed to shareholders in the company (or the owners of the company) via franked dividend payments. Australian Taxation Office statistics show that in the 2014-15 financial year, more than 95% of dividends paid to Australian households were franked. The fact that Australian business owners can claim back any tax paid by their businesses when they lodge their personal tax returns makes their personal income tax rate the more relevant concern to the potential profitability of their business. In addition, Pearson argued that company tax cuts would lead to higher wages, a statement supported by the Australian Treasury. The Treasury modelling shows that the wage hike would be the result of greater foreign investment in Australia, leaving the owners of small businesses needing to pay higher wages to attract or retain workers. Small business owners who receive their income via franked dividends won’t receive any tax relief to cover this expense. So it’s possible that cuts to the company tax rate could hinder small businesses, rather than benefit them. – Janine Dixon and Jason Nassios Blind review This verdict finds a reasonable level of support from the available data. Research from the University of Western Sydney published in 2014, based on HILDA data and Australian Bureau of Statistics data, found that business owner households (as opposed to individuals) reported an average weekly income of $1,975 in 2010. That’s around $103,000 per household. If there were two adults per household, this would equate to $51,500 per person. Also, because the ‘average’ is skewed upwards by high income earners, 50% of earners would earn less than the average, which lends further support to Pearson’s statement. Information published by an American company called PayScale suggests the average salary for a small business owner/operator in Australia is around $67,000 per year, and the median salary is $62,000. If true, this would not be consistent with the claim that almost 60% of small business owners earn less than $50,000 per year. However, this information is based on a survey with a relatively small sample size. This source is a private sector consulting firm, and no other detail on their data source is provided. – Ross Guest FactCheck Q A: are 'almost 60%' of small business owners paid '$50,000 or less'? The Conversation FactCheck is accredited by the International Fact-Checking Network. The Conversation’s FactCheck unit is the first fact-checking team in Australia and one of the first worldwide to be accredited by the International Fact-Checking Network, an alliance of fact-checkers hosted at the Poynter Institute in the US. Read more here. Have you seen a “fact” worth checking? The Conversation’s FactCheck asks academic experts to test claims and see how true they are. We then ask a second academic to review an anonymous copy of the article. You can request a check at checkit@theconversation.edu.au. Please include the statement you would like us to check, the date it was made, and a link if possible.

Authors: Janine Dixon, Economist at Centre of Policy Studies, Victoria University

Read more http://theconversation.com/factcheck-qanda-are-almost-60-of-small-business-owners-paid-50-000-or-less-91328

Australia Today

Strengthening ties between Australia and the USA

Malcolm Turnbull

The alliance between Australia and the United States has been broadened and deepened by my visit to Washington D.C.   In a reflection of the ongoing importance of the relationship, I held a successful meeting with President Donald J. Trump in the Oval Office at the White House.   Our fourth me...

Read more

Cochlear Implant Day this Sunday

Scott Tucker

 GIVING THE GIFT OF SOUND TO INDONESIANS     Minister for Trade and Industry, Niall Blair this week met with cochlear implant recip...

Read more

Nick Xenophon announces energy co-op to lower SA power bills

Erin Clare

An exciting plan to lower power prices using the co-operative model of community electricity trusts has been announced by SA BEST leader Nick Xenophon.   “The co-operative model has an internationally proven track record for delivering services,” said Business Council of Cooperatives and Mutuals...

Read more

Jodie & Soda rallied the community to make Alex the 'best firefighter ever'

Tina Liptai

  Adelaide has a new pint-size hero after Mix 102.3's Jodie & Soda rallied the community to make Alex the 'best firefighter ever'     ...

Read more

Barnaby Joyce: the story of an unlikely rise and a self-inflicted fall

Michelle Grattan, Professorial Fellow, University of Canberra

Joyce's departure to the backbench obviously brings immediate relief for the government and the Nationals. What it will mean beyond that is more difficult to predict.AAP/Marlon DaltonIn the end, the tough man crumpled. For a fortnight Barnaby Joyce had resembled someone out in the snow who’d b...

Read more

Top 10 Deadliest Building Fires in Australia

Geordie Killen

A few months from now, we're going to celebrate Fire Prevention Week and one of the best ways to understand the dangers of fire is to remember worst fire incidents in Australia. By reading the harrowing stories of these fire disasters, people will be more aware of how dangerous fires can be. It wi...

Read more

Arming teachers will only make US school shootings worse

Rick Sarre, Adjunct Professor of Law and Criminal Justice, University of South Australia

US President Donald Trump talks to high school students about safety on campus following the shooting deaths of 17 people at a Florida school.Reuters/Jonathan ErnstOn February 14, in Parkland, Florida, 17 teachers and students were shot dead at their school by an estranged student armed with a high-...

Read more

Holidays & Travel

Places That Will Make You Want to Visit Indonesia This Year

Royalty, culture and history coalesce in Yogyakarta     Seasoned travellers wanting more than boutique shopping, hip bars and cutting edge restaurants are invited to try a new Indonesian island or include one...

STA Travel: MASSIVE THREE DAY NEW ZEALAND SALE

NEW ZEALAND FLASH SALE!!!!    For the next THREE DAYS ONLY, STA Travel is having massive flight and Campervan hire sales for New Zealand!!    Fly one way for $129, and RETURN FOR $275!! Campervans start from $47 a day!    If...

MANTRA HOTELS LAUNCHES BIGGEST EVER GLOBAL SALE

Mantra Hotels is set to launch its biggest ever Global Sale with massive savings on more than 130 Mantra, Peppers, BreakFree and Art Series Hotels, booked between 13 - 21...

Bangkok's Winter Festival "Love and Warmth at Winter's End"

His Majesty King Maha Vajiralongkorn Bodindradebayavarangkun has graciously initiated the organisation of a winter festival under the theme 'Un Ai Rak Khlai Khwam Nao' (Love and Warmth at Winter's End)...

Give Your Valentine a Villa in Mykonos

Need a Last-Minute Valentine’s Day Gift?  For $66 Give Your Valentine a Villa in MykonosThis Valentine’s Day, if you are still debating on a meaningful gift for your loved one...

The Nam Hai Launches AntiGravityYoga and Unveils New Serenity Structure

Hoi An, Vietnam – Four Seasons Resort The Nam Hai, Hoi An is elevating its wellbeing offering with a new yoga pavilion and introduction of AntiGravity® Yoga, a dynamic 'flying' yoga...

Rydges South Bank rolls out the MAGIC CARPET to welcome Aladdin to Brisbane!

Rydges South Bank is rolling out their very own magic carpet to welcome the blockbuster stage show Disney’s Aladdin – The Musical to Brisbane, announcing an exclusive stay, taste and...

New cellar doors across Tasmania

New Cellar Door at Clover Hill Drawing inspiration from the form of a clover leaf, the new Clover Hill cellar door ( sits on the edge of the valley...

Club Med helps Aussies hack their holidays

This month, Club Med is helping Australians make the most of their annual leave and save more on the holidays of their dreams, by offering their best price all year...

Fashion & Beauty

The Most Stylish Women of All Time and How to Be Like Them

The mark of style is uniqueness. It’s not just in following the trends; it’s in being creative enough to set new ones in place. It’s about natural allure that draws...

Australian size-inclusive activewear label Active Truth

Mums and daughters #twinning in new activewear range that encourages healthy body image in women and girls Mums and daughters #twinning in new activewear range that encourages healthy body image im...

Bras N Things Heat Up The Night campaign

Inspired by hot summer nights and dazzling neon city lights, Bras N Things’ new Heat Up The Night campaign showcases stunning fashion lingerie, decadent embroidered lace and bold caging details.   Featuring...

Fashion Moment Holiday: Restyle Your Wardrobe and Enjoy Exclusive Shopping Privileges at Four Seasons

Adjacent to the prestigious IFC mall, Four Seasons Hotel Hong Kong has always been the venue of choice for the glam and glitterati to flaunt their fashion statements. Housing five...

Staying Fashionable on the Beach this Summer

Whether you’re travelling alone, with your partner for the first time or on a relaxing trip with your whole family or friend group, looking great while you’re on the beach...

Santamaria Shirt Makers

Traditional shirt-making for the modern era How the second generation of a traditional shirt maker is transforming the family business for the digital age From Madrid to London and now the world...

HEALTH

Cinzia Cozzolinos shares her 7 Day Feb-Fast Detox

Nutritionist and Founder of Nutrition Darling and Smoothie Bombs shares her 7 Day Feb-Fast Detox.  Cinzia Cozzolinos Tips are below and her 7 Day Plant Based Eating Plan is...

Malcolm Turnbull - Ground-breaking flu vaccines to protect millions of Aussies

The Turnbull Government will provide two new ground-breaking flu vaccines to over three million Australians aged 65 years and over - free of charge. This is a direct response to last...

Alcovit

Here we go a "new hangover cure", sure thing whatever.   Alcovit Australia states from the start it is NOT a Hangover Cure, it is NOT something that allows you to drink...

"Career mums" vs "home makers"

Mums today are adjusted into many different scenarios; whether you have a stay at home business, working only a couple of days a week whilst your children are with carers...

Seasonal health retreat in a box

A seasonal reminder to slow down can help manage anxiety and stress in Australian women. It’s back to work and back to the daily grind. Well-being expert, Holistic Nutritionist and Personal...

Surviving A Divorce

Breakups are tough at the best of times. When you’ve been married for some time, have a family, and find that your relationship has broken down beyond repair, the process...

LIFE STYLE

Get green with your gardening needs

Do you consider yourself a particularly green-fingered gardener who has a real love and passion for flowers and other shrubbery? If your answer to this questions is yes, then you...

5 Most Common Household Emergencies and How to Fix Them

If you have a large and old house, there’s a pretty big chance that there are going to be some emergencies every now and then. It’s important to maintain the...

How to Life Plan with Your Children’s Future in Mind

For most people, a big part of their life plan involves kids. Children are one of life’s great joys, but also one of life’s great financial burdens. The good news...

8 Easy Tips for Keeping Your Home Healthy and Clean

Although we see our homes as our safe havens, they aren’t actually as safe as we may think. In fact, there are probably numerous hidden toxins and allergens that we...

Cleaning Tips for Your Living Space in Australia

We all know that cleaning our home is extremely important; however, it seems that not all Aussies take this seriously and make some crucial mistakes when it comes to the...

Sydney Bayside Home Retreat for any family

Amid the leafy based greenery of The Sydney Suburb Putney resides a timeless new feature home setting to the modern 2018 family unit. The conjunction of bayside living, ambiance, tranquility...

FOOD & DINING

Tips for Drinking Wine around the World

Compromises are for relationships, not wine. – Sir Robert Scott Caywood Do you know how eating food from all over the world is in fact a unique way of traveling around...

Introducing Champagne lovers to, Emperor, Australia’s home of Champagne

Every bottle of Champagne ordered from Emperor is beautifully packaged in custom Emperor gift boxes or wrapping paper. Emperor houses the most extensive collection of champagne in Australia.   Kyla says:...

Hot Stuff: the strategically engineered reusable coffee cup combating Australia¹s landfill epidemic

As Australia’s caffeine addiction continues to soar, environmentalists warn that disposable coffee cups are fast on their way to becoming a major pollution hazard. According to the ABC (2016), coffee cups...

Get saucy this Valentine's Day with Lillie's Q

Whether you’re spending Valentine’s Day with a special partner or celebrating love with your friends, why not treat them (and yourself) to something a little different this year. Get your taste...

Winter Food and Wellness a Winning Combination for Aussies Travelling to Japan

Increased flight options, striking natural scenery, fascinating culture, world-famous onsens and delicious food: there are many reasons why the Australian love affair with Japan seems to be a never ending...

Move over avocado toast. This millennial has created healthy bake mixes

Back to work and school healthy snacks made with real ingredients. 29 year old Genevieve Le Hunt grabbed a gap in the baking mix market. Genevieve created Bake Mixes, organic, vegan...