Modern Australian



'Alexa, call my lawyer!' Are you legally liable if someone makes a purchase using your virtual assistant?

  • Written by Mark Giancaspro, Lecturer in Law, University of Adelaide

When Amazon launched its Alexa virtual assistant in 2014, it probably didn’t think that a bird would expose a potentially significant legal issue with the device. But an African grey parrot named Rocco, living in Blewbury, England, appears to have done just that.

Last month, Rocco made headlines for his habit of secretly ordering goods through his owner’s voice-activated Alexa device, which charges purchases to the linked Amazon account. The African grey species, which is renowned for its ability to mimic human speech, successfully ordered fruit, vegetables, ice-cream, a kettle, light bulbs and a kite.

Virtual assistants such as Alexa are growing in popularity. The number of users worldwide is projected to reach 1.8 billion by 2021. Unlike some rival models, such as Google Home, Alexa does not have individual voice recognition capability. Since Alexa cannot currently be trained to respond only to a selected person, anyone in your home could purchase items through your account.

Rocco’s ability to manipulate Alexa raises an important question: if someone made an unauthorised purchase on your Alexa device, would you be legally liable to pay for it?

The answer lies in contract law.

Read more: Digital assistants like Alexa and Siri might not be offering you the best deals

You are responsible

The setting for voice purchasing via Alexa can only be be switched on or off. That is, either the function is deactivated so that no one can make vocal purchase orders at all, or it’s calibrated to require a vocal confirmation code to authorise purchases.

In the first case, you cannot enjoy one of the technology’s most convenient features. In the second case, you are still susceptible to a third party – human or capable animal – overhearing and mimicking your voice to make illegitimate purchases. You must then act swiftly to cancel the order in time.

Amazon’s Conditions of Use, which govern voice purchasing through Alexa, state:

You are responsible for maintaining the confidentiality of your account and password and for restricting access to your account, and you agree to accept responsibility for all activities that occur under your account or password.

A golden rule of Australian contract law is that once you sign a contract you are deemed to have read, understood and accepted the terms – even if you haven’t. This is also the legal position in the US, whose laws govern the Amazon Conditions of Use.

So, when you sign up to use Alexa, you agree to be responsible for any purchases made on the device by you, your resident parrot, a mischievous friend or relative, or an unwelcome burglar. It doesn’t matter whether you intended the purchase or not.

Read more: There's a reason Siri, Alexa and AI are imagined as female – sexism

There are exceptions

If your pet is responsible, you will have a stronger case to avoid paying because animals other than humans lack the legal capacity to enter into contracts, so the transaction would be “voidable”. If a human is to blame, which is more likely, there is a legal exception that might still save you having to pay up.

'Alexa, call my lawyer!' Are you legally liable if someone makes a purchase using your virtual assistant? African grey parrots are very good at mimicking human speech.

Under both Australian and US law, where a party to a contract is mistaken about the identity of their counterpart, the contract may be void under the “doctrine of mistake”.

In Australia, this rule applies where parties do not contract face-to-face, which will always be the case when someone orders through Amazon via Alexa. The critical factor is “materiality” – you need to prove that mistaken identity was vitally important to the transaction.

This will be difficult given Amazon has no interest in who specifically is ordering its products, and the Alexa owner would not normally care who at Amazon’s end has processed the order. But the fact someone made a purchase without the owner’s permission in circumstances where they could not reasonably prevent it might suffice as “material” for the courts.

American law is similar. Section 153 of the influential Restatement (Second) of Contracts states that a party can plead mistake and escape the contract where the mistake is material, and:

  1. enforcing the contract would be unconscionable (unjust), or
  2. the other party had reason to know of the mistake or actually caused it through their own fault.

Amazon would never be at fault, nor able to tell if an unauthorised party made a purchase on Alexa, so you would need to prove that the transaction was unjust and that mistaken identity was critically important.

A potential snag is the exception stated in Section 154: this says that Section 153 won’t apply if you and the other party have agreed that you will bear the risk. It might come down to how a court reads the Amazon Conditions of Use.

Read more: Do I want an always-on digital assistant listening in all the time?

Legal precedents

Recent US court decisions emphasise that the mistake doctrine won’t apply where the other party’s identity is immaterial or irrelevant. Again, it would certainly be relevant where the Alexa owner had no way of preventing the unauthorised purchase (such as criminal activity). Enforcement would be grossly unfair in that situation.

The courts would probably not be as lenient if it were a friend, relative or pet doing the deed, as their use of Alexa is an assumed risk on the owner’s part. But it is still arguable that the owner should be legally excused because they had no involvement whatsoever in the purchase. The nature and value of the products purchased might also weigh into a court’s assessment.

To avoid a costly lawsuit, Alexa owners should deactivate voice purchasing when the unit is unsupervised, or discretely implement and use a confirmation code for voice purchases.

Users should also regularly check their accounts to ensure that any unauthorised purchases are picked up early and cancelled in time.

Finally, consider a dog instead of a parrot.

Authors: Mark Giancaspro, Lecturer in Law, University of Adelaide

Read more http://theconversation.com/alexa-call-my-lawyer-are-you-legally-liable-if-someone-makes-a-purchase-using-your-virtual-assistant-109075

The Conversation

NEWS

Deer Woman is a work of immense power and restraint

Cherish Violet Blood as Lila in Deer Woman, playing at this year's Sydney Festival. Prudence UptonReview: Deer Woman, Sydney FestivalOne of the most exhilarating things about Wesley Enoch’s tenure as...

Refuge City, a new kind of city for our times

A visualisation of a Refuge City street scene.Richard Weller/Julian Bolleter, Author providedAustralia is one of the most successful multicultural societies in the world. Nonetheless, in recent times many Australians have...

Back to work? Take lunch from home to save time and money – and boost your mood

Bringing your lunch and snacks to work could save you $600 to $1,800 a year.ShutterstockHeading back to work after the holidays means turning your thoughts to what’s for lunch. Are...

Top Tips For Trading CFD That Will Make 2019 Your Best Trading Year

It doesn't matter whether you are looking for CFD trading tips for your demo account or live account. One thing you should know is that becoming a better trader doesn't...

The business of sport - trends in Australia's commercial sports market

Australia has a deserved reputation as a nation of sport lovers. But sport is not just an enjoyable pastime or a way to keep fit. For thousands of Australians, sport...

What's the deal (or no-deal) with Brexit? Here's everything explained

On June 23, 2016 the United Kingdom held a referendum to decide whether it should leave or remain in the European Union. More than 30 million people took part in...

it's too late for the silent generation

Healthy people now in their 50s and 60s will be the first generations to benefit from reform. For people already in care, changes will come too late.from www.shutterstock.comA surprising group...

Why do so few Aussies speak an Australian language?

Linguistically speaking, Australia is special. With around 250 languages spoken when Australia was first colonised, Australia was one of the most linguistically diverse places in the world. But few people...

It's designers who can make gaming more accessible for people living with disabilities

Redressing a tendency to marginalise disability in games requires an awareness of disability at a design level. Humphrey Muleba/Unsplash, CC BYAnyone can play video games, right? If you’ve been following...

Ten ways teacher librarians improve literacy in schools

Australian schools constantly strive to improve the literacy outcomes of their students. Supporting literacy achievement for struggling readers is particularly important because these readers have their disadvantage compounded: capable students...

The financially well-off defy the stereotypes. They include retirees, and mortgagees

Financial well-being isn't always where you expect to find it, in part it depends on attitude.ShutterstockFinancial well-being is hard to get a handle on.That’s because it’s a mix of how...

the power of not being too clear

Specify what you want, and that might be all you'll get, whereas if you are vague...ShutterstockIncentives, in one form or other, are central to our lives.The Soviet experiment ended in...

Popular articles from Modern Australian

Budget Gifting Ideas That Teens Can UtiliseUnforgettable Attractions of Perth  A tour guide to MelbourneAussies Hate Saving Money for a TripTips for Optimising Your Shoulder Surgery Recovery PeriodMistakes You Must Avoid While Purchasing Furniture Do's and Don'ts for Louvre InstallationCreative Ways To Stay Fit In The New YearTop 5 Places to Visit in Australia8 Ways to Fight Inflammation6 Athlete Inspirations For Adopting The Gym LifeHow to Get Your Child Into Modelling: 5 Top Tips for Breaking Into the IndustryThe Best Design Trends for Creating a Restful BedroomBody Talk: Losing Weight and Gaining Good HealthWhy You Need To Get a Forex Trading Education