Modern Australian
Men's Weekly

.

forget court action – you won't win

  • Written by Michelle Grattan, Professorial Fellow, University of Canberra

Anthony Albanese says he has legal advice to back his move to have John Setka expelled from the ALP, warning him against wasting union members’ money on court action.

This followed fighting words on Monday from Setka, the Victorian construction boss of the Construction, Forestry, Maritime, Mining and Energy Union, who threatened that if Albanese tried to expel him without due process he would take legal action. But, speaking to The New Daily, he also admitted it would be costly and it would be “up to the members”.

Albanese last week had Setka suspended from the party and will move for his expulsion when its national executive meets on July 5.

The opposition leader originally targeted Setka primarily over denigrating remarks he was reported to have made at an internal union meeting about anti-domestic violence campaigner Rosie Batty.

But whether he did denigrate Batty is contested. While still maintaining his claim, Albanese stresses Setka’s history of inappropriate behaviour.

Setka had been on the front pages for a long period “for all the wrong reasons,” Albanese told Sky on Monday.

“He used his kids to send a very frank message to the ABCC [Australian Building and Construction Commission].

"He gave a speech at a rally in Melbourne where he spoke about knowing where people live, and people won’t be able to go to their local sporting clubs and their local activities. It essentially was an attempt at intimidation that can only be viewed in that way.”

Read more: Lambie's vote key if government wants to have medevac repealed

On Batty, Setka had conceded he mentioned her, Albanese said. “He concedes that it was in the context of his [pending] court case and he concedes that he has spoken about him not getting a fair go in that.

"In what way is it possible that he raised Rosie Batty without criticising her work? It’s very clear that that was the context.”

Albanese said the ALP as an organisation had the right to determine who joined. “The national executive has complete power to determine membership issues – that’s been dealt with in the courts before,” he said.

His message to “anyone who wishes to waste money on legal cases, particularly using … the members of the union’s money” was that such action would fail. The ALP had legal advice and was going through the proper process.

Setka claimed in his New Daily interview the real reason for the expulsion move was that he threatened at the union meeting to stop funding to the ALP. “What I said was no more money to the ALP. […] Not one more cent.”

Read more: VIDEO: Michelle Grattan on John Setka, press freedom, Adani approval and tax

Setka is also resisting pressure from a growing list of unions to quit his union position. ACTU secretary Sally McManus last week urged him to stand down, citing the court case in which he is accused of using a carriage vehicle to harass a woman (he has said he plans to plead guilty).

McManus and the unions supporting her are concerned that his behaviour conflicts with the union movement’s strong stand against domestic violence and in general is damaging to the general standing of a movement which has become increasingly feminised.

Unions which have called on Setka to resign his union position include the Australian Nursing and Midwifery Federation, the National Tertiary Education Union, the National Union of Workers, the Finance Sector Union, the Community and Public Sector Union, the Australian Education Union, the Independent Education Union, the Media, Entertainment and Arts Alliance, the Australian Services Union, the Australian Workers’ Union, United Voice, the Shop, Distributive and Allied Employees Association, and the Transport Workers Union.

Authors: Michelle Grattan, Professorial Fellow, University of Canberra

Read more http://theconversation.com/albanese-to-setka-forget-court-action-you-wont-win-118932

What a Compulsory Acquisition Lawyer Does and When You Need One

When a government authority needs land for a road or other public works, it can require an owner to sell through compulsory acquisition. That can fe...

Electrician Geelong and Reliable Power for Modern Living

Reliable electricity underpins comfort, safety, and productivity in homes and businesses, and electrician Geelong services are central to keeping s...

Pipe Floats Enhancing Stability in Floating Hose and Pipeline Systems

Floating pipeline systems operate in environments where movement is constant and conditions are unpredictable. Water currents, wave action, changing...

Common Legal Challenges Solved by Commercial Lawyers in Melbourne

Running a business often involves navigating legal issues that can interrupt growth if left unresolved. This article will explore the most common ch...

Engineered Timber Floors Melbourne: A Refined Flooring Choice For Modern Homes

Flooring decisions influence both the appearance and performance of a home for decades. As homeowners seek materials that balance natural beauty wit...

Whiteboard Systems Supporting Clear Thinking and Visual Planning

Effective communication often starts with making ideas visible. A whiteboard provides a clean, flexible surface where thoughts can be organised, share...

BMW Used Cars and the Appeal of Driving German Engineering

For drivers who value performance, comfort, and refined design, BMW used cars Melbourne offer an attractive way to experience premium motoring without...

Why Automatic Gates Melbourne are A Smarter Property Access

Security and convenience have become defining features of modern properties, and automatic gates Melbourne are increasingly seen as a practical sol...

The Importance Of Structured Commercial Office Cleaning In Busy Office Environments

Office spaces are dynamic environments where people collaborate, meet clients, and spend a significant portion of their day. Maintaining cleanliness...

Single Tooth Dental Implant for Natural Tooth Replacement and Lasting Stability

Losing a single tooth can have a noticeable impact on comfort, appearance, and confidence, which is why a Single Tooth Dental Implant is considered...

When Grief Doesn’t Follow a Timeline

Grief rarely moves in a straight line. It doesn’t follow stages neatly, and it doesn’t respond well to pressure — especially the quiet pressure ...

Steel Plate And Its Role In Modern Construction And Manufacturing

A steel plate is one of those materials that quietly holds the modern world together. It does not demand attention, yet it supports bridges, buildin...

Understanding Fat Transfer to the Breast: What to Know Before Considering the Procedure

Surgical options for breast enhancement have evolved over time, offering different approaches depending on a person’s goals and body type. One opt...

What to Do When Your Car’s Side Window Is Broken

A shattered side window is more than an inconvenience. Whether caused by a break-in, road debris, or accidental impact, it leaves your vehicle exposed...

Shopify Web Development and Shopify Website Development for Scalable Online Stores

Choosing the right platform is a crucial decision for any online business, and Shopify web development has become a popular choice for brands that ...

How a Burleigh Heads Plumber Tests for Pipe Leaks

Pipe leaks can be deceptively difficult to spot. Some announce themselves with a steady drip under the sink, but many develop quietly behind walls, ...

What Local Businesses Should Expect from IT Services in Melbourne?

If you run a Melbourne business with roughly 7–100 staff, you have probably noticed something over the last couple of years. The IT problems got m...

How Professional Cleaning Improves Indoor Air Quality

Indoor air quality (IAQ) plays a crucial role in our health, comfort, and overall wellbeing. Australians spend nearly 90% of their time indoors-at hom...