Modern Australian

Who am I? Why am I here? Why children should be taught philosophy (beyond better test scores)

  • Written by Ben Kilby, PhD student in Education, researching Philosophy for Children, Monash University

In a recent TED talk titled No Philosophy, No Humanity, author Roger Sutcliffe asked the audience whether a flagpole was a place. Around half the audience said yes, the other said no.

He went on to describe the response a nine-year-old gave him to that question:

to me a flagpole is not a place, but to an ant it is.

This creative perspective shows what children can do when given space to perform philosophical thinking.

Critical thinking skills are highly valued in society, and are beginning to be valued more in education. A Critical and Creative Thinking capability was introduced into the Australian and Victorian Curriculum in 2017.

The Australian Curriculum notes:

Responding to the challenges of the twenty-first century – with its complex environmental, social and economic pressures – requires young people to be creative, innovative, enterprising and adaptable, with the motivation, confidence and skills to use critical and creative thinking purposefully.

This capability isn’t meant to be taught as a standalone subject, but through other learning areas. One content descriptor states students should be able to consider when analogies might be used in expressing a point of view.

Who am I? Why am I here? Why children should be taught philosophy (beyond better test scores) Is a flag pole a place? Maybe for an ant. from

This is exactly what philosophy teaches children. And this can be done through a program specifically tailored to primary school aged children, known as Philosophy for Children, or P4C.

Programs in Philosophy for Children have shown significant benefits for students around the world. These benefits include improvement in academic results, as well as less measurable outcomes such as helping children make sense of their place in the world.

What is Philosophy for Children?

The idea of doing philosophy with children began in the 70s when Matthew Lipman and Ann Sharp developed the first P4C program in primary schools.

In the last 50 years, Philosophy for Children has spread to more than 60 countries. It has gone on to influence university level philosophy, the business world and has also been used in prisons.

In these programs, children discuss issues around ethics or questions of personal identity. These are fundamental to understanding ourselves, especially during the formative years of school where young people are developing their identities.

For instance, students in Years 1 and 2 can analyse the ethics of truth-telling and explore whether it matters if the lie produces a positive outcome, or whether the intention of the liar matters, or whether it matters if it was an insignificant little white lie.

Read more: What's the point of education? It's no longer just about getting a job

Students in Years 5 and 6 can discuss their interpretation of how gender identity is formed. This can generate questions such as: is gender tied to sex, does gender happen at birth or do you develop a gender, and can people identify as a particular gender?

In Australia, Philosophy for Children is still largely unfunded and relies on volunteer-based institutions such as the Victorian Association of Philosophy in Schools (VAPS).

Schools such as Brunswick East Primary and Lloyd Street Primary have run successful Philosophy for Children programs for many years. But, with little outside support available, school staff must develop the program and embed it into their own curriculum.

Ireland has embraced Philosophy for Children and given philosophy a core place in the Irish education system. President Michael D. Higgins introduced the program by saying

an exposure to philosophy – as method and revelation, as rational exercise and imaginative journey – is […] vital if we truly want our young people to acquire the capacities they need in preparing for their journey into the world.

The UK has also funded research worth more than A$2 million to evaluate outcomes of Philosophy for Children programs at primary school level (scheduled for completion in 2021).

How do we know it’s effective?

A long-term study that began in Spain in 2002 followed more than 400 students in a P4C group and another 300 who weren’t involved in the programs in philosophy. It showed children in the P4C group gained an extra seven IQ points and were prone to more social behaviour over the 12-year project.

One of the largest UK studies involved more than 3,000 students in Years 4 and 5 in a randomised trial. This study concluded students engaged in the P4C program gained an extra two months progress in maths and reading compared to those who didn’t over the course of a year.

Read more: Want to improve NAPLAN scores? Teach children philosophy

Philosophy is a broad subject. It helps develop skills that can be transferred to other academic areas. This partly explains how philosophy programs improve test scores in reading, writing and mathematics without children having to actually do any reading, writing or mathematics.

Who am I? Why am I here? Why children should be taught philosophy (beyond better test scores) Philosophy skills extend into other subject areas. from

These skills range from clarity and coherence in speaking and listening to providing reasons for arguments, constructing counter-examples, and using analogical reasoning.

In the US, students who major in philosophy have some of the highest test scores when applying for graduate school. In 2014, philosophy majors had the highest average score in the LSAT (law school test) and the GRE – a standardised test used to assess applicants for graduate school in most disciplines. Philosophy majors came fourth out of 31 majors in the GMAT (business school test).

Read more: Bertrand Russell and the case for 'Philosophy for Everyone'

It’s about more than test scores

The benefits of philosophy stretch far beyond its measurable effects.

Most P4C practitioners find something inherently valuable in facilitating philosophical dialogues with groups of young people – something we consider more valuable than the improved test scores that might impress educational administrators.

Philosophy is about life. It’s about being engaged with life. It’s about being in the world. Asking ethical questions allows us to reflect on how our actions affect the world. The value to these young people goes far beyond their test scores, their use of critical thinking skills or their future employment options.

They are engaged members of a thinking community. They deliberate, negotiate, and contemplate with respectful and thoughtful dialogue. Philosophy for Children can help improve academic results, but the reason it should be used in schools is because it allows children a space to make sense of the world and meaning in their lives.

Authors: Ben Kilby, PhD student in Education, researching Philosophy for Children, Monash University

Read more


As weary Britons head to the polls again, parties seem incapable of handling the nation's problems

The cost of running the 2017 UK general election was estimated at £140 million (A$270 million). It’s likely to be higher this time. In 2017, the Conservatives, Labour and the...

I had an idea in the 1980s and to my surprise, it changed education around the world

Cogitive load theory explains why explicit guidance from teachers is more effective in teaching students new content and skills than letting them discover these for themselves.from shutterstock.comThis is the first...

Indonesian cave paintings show the dawn of imaginative art and human spiritual belief

This hunting scene, painted 44,000 years ago, is the oldest known work of representational art in the world.Ratno Sardi, Author providedOur team has discovered a cave painting in Indonesia that...

As simple as finding a job? Getting people out of social housing is much more complex than that

A private member’s bill, moved by Labor MP Josh Burns, recently called on the Australian government “to help build more affordable homes” in response to the growing homelessness crisis...

a new film tells us little about the woman fixed in the role of musician's muse

Marianne Ihlen: she remains stuck in the role of the beautiful ingénue, the part-time lover, in Nick Broomfield's documentary.Copyright Nick BroomfieldNick Broomfield’s latest documentary, Marianne & Leonard: Words of Love...

What limits shareholder activism as a force for good: the free-rider problem

Shareholder activism involves directly engaging with directors and executives of companies to effect change.www.shutterstock.comThe board of Australia’s second-biggest bank is in for some stick at its annual general meeting today...

How New Zealanders miss out on hundreds of thousands in retirement savings

New Zealanders pay higher fees for KiwiSaver funds than people elsewhere.from, CC BY-NDIn the 12 years since New Zealand introduced the retirement fund KiwiSaver, nearly three million New Zealanders...

6 things to think about if you want a baby and 1 if you don't

A successful pregnancy if you have diabetes comes down to planning and making sure you have the right health-care team behind you.from www.shutterstock.comThe number of people with diabetes is expected...

Australian law doesn't go far enough to legislate affirmative consent. NSW now has a chance to get it right

NSW is undergoing a review of its sexual consent laws.From shutterstock.comThe NSW Law Reform Commission will hand down its final recommendations for a reformed definition of sexual consent in the...

riders daring to fly in a crazy desert race

Finke desert racers travel at more than 160 kilometres an hour, risking life and limb. Madman FilmsReview: Finke: There & Back, directed by Dylan RiverThe Finke Desert Race takes place...

Now Australian cities are choking on smoke, will we finally talk about climate change?

I moved to Sydney less than five weeks ago and the city has been shrouded in smoke haze on and off since then. I joke this is my “Sydney hazing”...

ancient penguins were as tall as people. We've discovered the species that started the downsizing trend

The newly discovered _Kupoupou stilwelli_ would have once swam in the waters around Chatham Island near New Zealand.Illustration by Jacob Blokland, Author providedA new species of extinct penguin has been...

Popular articles from Modern Australian

Stress Less - 5 Tips For Getting Through The Holiday Season On A Shoestring BudgetMesmerising Interior Design Trends for 2020 That Will Transform Your HomeTips for Sports BettingWhat Essentials to Consider to Avail Right Insurance Policy6 Essential Features You Should Consider Before Buying a Ski WatchNew or Used Car: How to Select The Best For Your FamilyChoosing a home builder in SydneyWhy regular visits to the eye doctor are important6 Budget Tips for a Student Studying Abroad in Australia5 Ways to Style Your Winter Wardrobe Essentials Into Versatile Outfits5 Brisbane Summer Classes Your Teens Can AttendSummer Gardening Tips4 Tips to Prepare for a Home Meditation RetreatWhy You Should Hit the Gym This SpringSaving History One VHS Tape At A Time