Modern Australian

'Courageous' investment means innovation stays in NZ, not sold off overseas

  • Written by Jessica C Lai, Associate Professor in Commercial Law, Te Herenga Waka — Victoria University of Wellington
'Courageous' investment means innovation stays in NZ, not sold off overseas

New Zealand is in an economic recession and the government is trying to spend its way through it with direct investment to boost the economy and jobs.

At the same time, the Reserve Bank of New Zealand (RNBZ) plans to lend retail banks money at low interest rates in the hope they are — as the reserve bank governor, Adrian Orr, put it — “courageous” in their lending choices.

But as the money does not need to be used for any particular type of venture, there are concerns it will inflame the already overheated property market.

Part of the problem is New Zealanders do not have many investment options. There is little to be “courageous” about.

This lack of investment options is partly due to the average New Zealander’s model of successful innovation.

Read more: With house prices soaring again the government must get ahead of the market and become a 'customer of first resort'

Most of the big successful New Zealand innovation stories we see in the media are about people who sold their innovation to an overseas – typically American – company. This success allows the innovator to buy their “three Bs”: the Beamer, the boat and the bach.

But is this a true measure of successful innovation? Or could we do better to create more investment options and allow for more “courageous” investment?

Investment in local industry

Innovation involves creating and capturing value from new things – whether products, services or processes.

The New Zealand model of successful innovation is narrowly about creation, perhaps setting up and then selling a start-up. This model is shaped by skill shortages, funding issues and risk aversion, which limit innovative growth.

Big ideas struggle to grow in New Zealand. The model is about innovators capturing short-term value for their creations.

What might be truly beneficial to New Zealand is if innovations stayed here and more risks were taken locally.

If more investment was directed at commercialisation of local innovations they could be used to create and grow local industries. The resulting products or services could then be exported or licensed internationally to bring more wealth into New Zealand.

This would create more investment opportunities, as well as jobs and local know-how. In turn, wealth could be created and distributed across communities for a sustained period.

It’s worth pointing out that innovation is self-perpetuating. Once an innovative industry is developed in an area, this can generate further innovation in that area, because of skill development and the localisation of these skills. Silicon Valley exemplifies this.

Learn from the Māori perspective

We need not look far to find an alternative model of successful innovation.

Talk to Māori communities and you hear that successful innovation is something that is implemented locally and creates value throughout the community.

During community consultation to develop Te Matarau a Māui – a regional Māori economic development strategy for the greater Wellington region – we were told time and again that the common strategic goal of “play to win” was too narrow.

A Māori perspective on innovation doesn’t focus on winners and losers, but on a vibrant blossoming innovation ecosystem. Innovation from this perspective is tied up with cultural knowledge and community identity.

This kind of innovation model leads to better distributed and long-term wealth creation, since value is embedded within and spread throughout the community.

Yet the tools, such as the Business Model Canvas, that we use to explore business ideas are based on hyper-individualistic, win-at-all-costs businesses.

New Zealand needs entrepreneurship and innovation tools that embed a richer perspective on success, more in line with the aspirations of the wellbeing economy and the Māori communities that developed Te Matarau a Māui.

A look to the future

We are not saying individual innovators should not be rewarded for their innovations. They should be. Nor are we saying that there aren’t success stories that involve local commercialisation. There are.

Moreover, we are not suggesting New Zealanders do not look outwards. They absolutely should.

But perhaps New Zealanders could shift their understanding of a success story for innovation, because we could have more innovation stories that involve further growth and benefit the well-being of communities.

Such a shift cannot happen until there is money to undertake the necessary risk to produce Kiwi innovations locally. International intellectual property portfolios should be developed in important markets, but we should invest in local capabilities to maintain operations in New Zealand. This would feed the New Zealand economy.

Read more: New data privacy rules are coming in NZ — businesses and other organisations will have to lift their games

More provocatively, keeping innovations local would create more business opportunities that New Zealanders could invest in, aside from real estate. Perhaps this could help to cool down the property market.

So in light of RBNZ’s role to “promote the prosperity and well-being of New Zealanders”, contribute to a “sustainable and productive economy” and support “maximum sustainable employment”, perhaps it should think about tying its lending scheme to making sure local innovation stays local. Otherwise, we might be letting a good crisis go to waste.

Authors: Jessica C Lai, Associate Professor in Commercial Law, Te Herenga Waka — Victoria University of Wellington

Read more https://theconversation.com/courageous-investment-means-innovation-stays-in-nz-not-sold-off-overseas-150381

NEWS

A vaccine will be a game-changer for international travel. But it's not everything

ShutterstockThe United Kingdom yesterday became the first country to approve the Pfizer/BioNTech COVID-19 vaccine for widespread use. Following a review by the country’s drug regulator, the UK government announced it...

Researchers, librarians, filmmakers and teachers are eager for the copyright reforms the government has promised

Ea Maples/Unsplash, CC BYIn August, the communications minister announced a series of changes to copyright laws to “better support the needs of Australians and public institutions to access material in...

From 'arse-ropes' to 'flying venom', a history of how we have come to talk about viruses and medicine

Wes Mountain/The Conversation, CC BY-NDSymptom, virus, epidemic, quarantine.We’ve become used to these terms in 2020. But the “COVID-19 vocabulary” might have been very different had it not been for a...

the singlet — a short history of an Australian icon

'Shearing sheep, Barcaldine District', 1948Queensland State Archives, Item ID ITM1154347There’s no denying the popularity of the singlet. The Chesty Bond, Australia’s best known singlet, has notched up more than 350...

China plays reverse 'poke the bear'

In the moment, Scott Morrison’s angry denunciation of the offensive Chinese tweet about alleged Australian war crimes seemed a reasonable response.In retrospect, it was probably ill-judged. This is so even...

Should Australians be worried about waiting for a COVID vaccine when the UK has just approved Pfizer's?

ShutterstockThe news that Pfizer’s COVID-19 vaccine has gained emergency approval in the United Kingdom and may be distributed to selected high-risk groups as early as next week is welcome.Headlines also...

Climate change is resulting in profound, immediate and worsening health impacts, over 120 researchers say

ShutterstockClimate change is resulting in profound, immediate and worsening health impacts, and no country is immune, a major new report from more than 120 researchers has declared. This year’s annual...

6 unis had Hindi programs. Soon there could be only 1, and that's not in Australia's best interests

La Trobe University is in talks to discontinue its Hindi program, along with Greek and Indonesian. In the mid-1990s, six Australian universities taught Hindi. If La Trobe ends its program...

Thomas Banks’ Quest for Love tackles life as a gay man with disability

Thomas Banks' Quest for LoveReview: Thomas Banks’ Quest for Love, directed by Pip KellyIn Thomas Banks’ Quest for Love, Banks — a writer and comedian with cerebral palsy — addresses...

Why can politicians so easily dodge accountability for their mistakes? The troubling answer: because they can

Damian Shaw/AAPIn recent days, the issue of government accountability was brought into sharp focus — again — when NSW Premier Gladys Berejiklian admitted that community grants awarded primarily to councils...

Feeling sore after exercise? Here's what science suggests helps (and what doesn't)

ShutterstockHave you been hitting the gym again with COVID restrictions easing? Or getting back into running, cycling, or playing team sports?As many of you might’ve experienced, the inevitable muscle soreness...

Eliminating most homelessness is achievable. It starts with prevention and 'housing first'

The stereotype of a homeless person – those living in tents or sleeping in parks or doorways – is just the visible tip of the much larger crisis of homelessness...



News Co Media Group

Content & Technology Connecting Global Audiences

More Information - Less Opinion













Popular articles from Modern Australian

Be Smart Before Buying That CarWater Costs in SydneyThe Pros and Cons of Artificial Christmas TreesThe most popular types of rouletteMaintaining your asphalt driveway is made easy with these pointers5 Effective Car Mods for Absolute BeginnersYour New Home Needs A Great GardenHow To Identify Signs Of Stress In Your ChildInstalling Shade Sails On your Garden10 Tips for Clearing a Blocked DrainCarpet Cleaning: Where Is It Headed In The Future?Common Repairs to Shipping ContainersThe lifestyle Choices of the Australian Millennials5 Tips For Creating a Kid-Friendly Backyard