Modern Australian
Men's Weekly

.

How FTX Australia was able to get away with claiming it was 'ASIC-licenced'

  • Written by Pamela Hanrahan, Professor of Commercial Law and Regulation, UNSW Business School, UNSW Sydney
How FTX Australia was able to get away with claiming it was 'ASIC-licenced'

When cryptocurrency exchange FTX Group collapsed in the Bahamas last month, its local subsidiaries FTX Australia Pty Ltd and FTX Express Pty Ltd fell over too.

The Australian companies were placed into administration on November 11 and within days the Australian Securities and Investments Commission (ASIC) had suspended the Australian financial service licence FTX Australia had held since March 2022.

The fact that FTX Australia had an Australian financial service came as a surprise to some people, who had wrongly assumed everything crypto-related was beyond the reach of Australia’s regulators.

It also raised questions – including for Assistant Treasurer Stephen Jones – about how FTX Australia managed to acquire its Australian financial services licence, and how ASIC seemed to have missed the chance to intervene sooner.

And it draws wider attention to the 20-year-old licensing system and what an Australian financial service actually means for the firms that have them.

Licensed to do what, precisely?

FTX Trading Limited When FTX commenced operations in Australia this year, its media release was headed: “FTX launches fully registered and licensed Australian operations”. But what exactly was it licensed to do? The Australian financial service (AFS) licensing regime in place since the late 1990s authorises each firm to do specified things, in relation to specified financial products, for specified clients. Each firm’s licence is different, and what is required by ASIC is different depending on what the firm is authorised to do. FTX Australia’s licence authorised it to deal in, make a market for, and provide general advice relating to derivatives and foreign exchange contracts to retail and wholesale clients. That’s it. Note that crypto-assets are not specified, nor is running a crypto-asset exchange. The jury is still out globally on whether crypto-assets (as distinct from investments derived from crypto-assets) are financial products at all. It is possible to think of them as like gold bullion or fine art – or pet rocks – where the asset itself is not a financial product, but a financial product might be constructed from it. If a cryptocurrency is not a financial product, then licensing laws can’t apply, which might explain why one of the two firms set up in Australia – FTX Express, which operated the crypto-exchange – was not AFS licensed. Read more: 'I thought crypto exchanges were safe': the lesson in FTX's collapse The lesson is that knowing a firm has an AFS licence only takes you so far, and often not very far at all. Unless you check the specific authorisations, there’s no way of knowing how little the firm you are dealing with is licensed to do. And ASIC-regulation doesn’t involve prudential regulation, which is directed at the stability of the company itself, ensuring among other things that it should be able to meet its financial commitments under reasonable circumstances. Prudential regulation is the job of the Australian Prudential Regulation Authority, which regulated neither FTX Australia nor FTX Express. Licences for sale FTX Australia’s ASIC licence was originally granted to someone else entirely back in 2008. A series of takeovers meant it passed through a number of hands until it ended up with FTX in March this year. While an original applicant has to satisfy rigorous checks, this hasn’t always been the case for subsequent purchasers. ASIC has known for years that its ASF licences were ending up in new hands when companies were bought and sold. In 2017, it asked the government’s ASIC Enforcement Review Taskforce to recommend changes to the law that would allow it to revisit an AFS licence when its owners changed. The change that was eventually legislated in 2020 only required licensees to notify ASIC when a licence changed hands, within 30 days. It did not require ASIC to approve the change in control. Limited ASIC powers ASIC is able to inquire further to determine whether there is reason to believe a new licensee was likely to contravene its statutory obligations or is “fit and proper” – but it is not required to do so. If it finds either that the licensee is likely to contravene its obligations or that it is not fit and proper, it is able to suspend or cancel the licence after giving the new owners a fair hearing. Read more: How 'bad credit' lender Cigno has dodged ASIC's grasp But such inquiries have not become routine. Most of the (hundreds of) licensee purchases notified each year seem to go through to the keeper, as did FTX’s. Even if ASIC had reviewed FTX’s purchase of the licence in March 2022, it might well have found no grounds to revoke it, given the very limited range of activities it authorised. The FTX collapse may result in ASIC changing its attitude to change-of-control transactions involving AFS licensees, for which it might need more resources. But even if that happens, clients would still be well advised to take care to understand exactly what “AFS licensed” really means. Authors: Pamela Hanrahan, Professor of Commercial Law and Regulation, UNSW Business School, UNSW Sydney

Read more https://theconversation.com/how-ftx-australia-was-able-to-get-away-with-claiming-it-was-asic-licenced-196361

Someone Trips at Your Fundraiser. Now What? Understanding Public Liability for NFPs

Three months of planning. Volunteers giving up their weekends. Sponsorships chased, catering sorted, tables decorated. And then, about an hour into ...

Stainless Steel Tube: A Complete Specification Guide for Engineers, Project Managers, and Industrial Buyers

Few materials in the industrial and manufacturing world are as universally relied upon — or as frequently misspecified — as stainless steel tube...

How to Choose the Right Barber Shears Scissors for Professional Results

Since a barber is only as good as their tool, choosing the right barber shear scissor must not be taken lightly. Most barbers end up buying the first ...

Why Commercial Construction Companies Play A Critical Role In Modern Urban Development

Urban development requires highly organised planning, engineering expertise, and professional construction teams capable of delivering complex build...

Essential Features for Comfortable Family Caravan Trips

Choosing the right van for family travel requires careful consideration of how the space will be used on a daily basis. Families have specific needs...

Chatswood Tutor: Helping Students Achieve Academic Success With Personalised Learning

Education plays a crucial role in shaping a student’s future, and many students benefit from additional academic support outside the classroom. A pr...

How External Consulting Can Guide Enterprise IT Strategy and Procurement

Internal IT teams carry deep operational knowledge, but that familiarity can create blind spots in strategic decisions. An external IT consultant br...

Why Sports Nutrition Australia Is Important for Performance and Recovery

Athletes and fitness enthusiasts place significant demands on their bodies during training and competition. Maintaining energy levels, supporting mu...

How Body Contouring Bundoora Helps Improve Shape And Confidence

Modern aesthetic treatments have made it possible to refine body shape without the need for invasive surgery. One of the most popular non-surgical o...

Why Plantation Shutters Are a Stylish and Practical Choice for Modern Homes

Window coverings play a major role in the comfort, privacy, and overall design of a home. Homeowners often look for solutions that provide both visu...

Why a Retractable Hose Reel Is Essential for Efficient Water Management

Managing hoses efficiently is important for both residential and commercial environments. Whether watering gardens, cleaning outdoor areas, or maint...

Best Ways to Trade In Your Old Tech for Cash in Australia

Upgrading your mobile is exciting, but many Australians are left wondering what to do with the device they no longer use. Instead of leaving it in a...

Why Doctors in Bundoora Play an Important Role in Community Health

Access to quality healthcare is essential for maintaining a healthy lifestyle and managing medical conditions effectively. Visiting experienced doctor...

Backyard Aesthetics Decoded: Mediterranean, Coastal, Retro, Rustic, and Beyond

Backyard design has come a long way from a patch of lawn, a barbecue in the corner, and a few chairs chosen purely for practicality. Today, outdoor ...

What Stops a Home From Feeling Flat-Pack Generic

There is nothing wrong with convenience. Flat-pack furniture, fast styling decisions, and online checkouts have made it easier than ever to furnish ...

5 Best Dental Clinics in Beecroft, NSW

The best dental clinics in Beecroft, NSW are Beecroft Smiles Dental Surgery, Beecroft Elegant Dental Clinic, McConnell Dental, Dentistry for Life, a...

Executive Recruitment: Finding Leadership Talent That Drives Organisational Success

Hiring the right leadership team can significantly influence the direction and performance of any organisation. Strong executives bring strategic thin...

Understanding the Importance of Abrasive Blasting in Industrial Surface Preparation

Surface preparation is an essential step in many industrial processes. Whether preparing metal structures, removing old coatings, or cleaning equipmen...