Jay Carmichael's gay love story set in conservative 1950s Australia intrigues, but fails to convince
- Written by: Peter Robinson, Honorary Senior Lecturer, UNSW Sydney
Marlo, a gay love story set in 1950s conservative Australia, draws on library and archival research. We know this because at the end of his book, author Jay Carmichael – a gay man himself – cites the work of Denis Altman and myself (in my role as a gay historian), among others. The novel is illustrated with photographs from collections in the State Library of Victoria and the Australian Queer Archives.
Review: Marlo – Jay Carmichael (Scribe)
Marlo concerns central character Christopher’s sexual coming-of-age, after moving to Melbourne as a young adult from the small country town of Marlo in East Gippsland. The novel explores how same-sex-attracted men lived their lives during the repressive period following the end of the second world war.
Repressive society, repressed self
In places, Jay Carmichael’s prose is inspired and elegiac:
And in the morning, before the world was clear-eyed, we would go, quiet, to our days.
On one occasion, as the physical relationship develops between Christopher and Morgan, he investigates Morgan’s body for any evidence of self harm:
In the shower, I checked his arms for self-inflicted scars or marks […] He did not have a blemish, but I determined he carried them within.
But he shows less interest in Morgan’s arms, thighs, genitals – or anything approaching the erotic.
It seems somewhat odd also that as a man in his 20s, ruminating over his budding physical relationship with Morgan, Christopher continued to use the term “things” to describe his genitals. (Which readers were first introduced to when as a child, his friend, Kings, showed Christopher his “things”.)
The connection the author might have intended here – between a repressive external society and an internalised, repressed view of the self – was not something my research revealed in men who were born in the 1920s and ‘30s and were sexually active in 1950s Australia. Many admitted to cautiously conducting their social/sexual relationships to avoid attracting the attention of homophobes, others to positively welcoming the police raiding their parties – for the “mystique” it brought them.
Read more: Faggots, punks, and prostitutes: the evolving language of gay men
Occasional jarring notes occurred when other present-day features intruded in this novel set in the 1950s – when, for example, picnickers in the Botanic Gardens had “bubbly” with lunch. (I am not a cultural historian but suspect that, if drunk in Melbourne in the 1950s, champagne was the preserve of a small elite.) The scene seems more like a present-day invention than a reflection of the past.
And, when Christopher had a “duvet” over his legs and later opened a bottle of “merlot” after finishing work in a mechanics’ garage, my credulity as a reader was tested.
While these factual anomalies might seem slight, they may cause readers to wonder about the author’s other historical representations.
Homosexuality was illegal in Australia in the period when Marlo is set.
State Library New South Wales collection: 'Home and Away', Author provided
In my view, a weakness of the novel is its focus on what I suspect are the author and his peers’ current concerns (such as self-harm). Forcing these and other improbable material features on the past suggests an insufficiently strong understanding of history.
There is an important difference between using our current interests to investigate the past, which Carmichael suggests he is doing, but did not do well in my view (the author’s note explaining his sources runs to eight pages) and imposing our present-day concerns on the past. I suspect he has done the latter.
Some writers of historical novels are known to spend months verifying everyday facts from the past: dress, modes of social interaction, food, drink and diet (for instance).
Examples of those who have excelled in this field include Mary Renault (The Persian Boy and other books in her Alexander the Great trilogy), Marguerite Yourcenar, first woman elected to the French Academy (Memoirs of Hadrian, Coup de Grâce), and more recently, Hilary Mantel (Wolf Hall).
When done well, the historical novel shows how good writing and a strong grasp of history can enhance a richer understanding of the past.
Authors: Peter Robinson, Honorary Senior Lecturer, UNSW Sydney
