Modern Australian
Men's Weekly

.

Bitter struggle in Liberals for likely poisoned chalice, as Jacinta Price defects from Nationals

  • Written by Michelle Grattan, Professorial Fellow, University of Canberra

By late last week it was clear Labor would win the election, but it came as more of a surprise when Peter Dutton lost the Queensland seat of Dickson he’d held since 2001.

Nor did many anticipate Greens leader Adam Bandt, member for Melbourne since 2010, would be swept away, in a lower house rout that has seen the minor party stripped of three of its four House of Representative seats.

Both the Liberals and the Greens are in existential moments, in need of new leaders and some painful introspections about their future directions.

Thinking back to the Liberal experience after Kevin Rudd’s 2007 victory, some wonder why anyone would be putting up their hand for the party leadership.

The Liberals churned through three leaders between 2007 and 2009. Brendan Nelson took over the party after Labor’s victory; undermined by Malcolm Turnbull, he lasted less than a year. Turnbull survived just over a year before being ousted by Tony Abbott.

Admittedly the experience of Peter Dutton was different – he was given a full term as opposition leader.

But the chances of Dutton’s successor becoming prime minister will be very low. With the added seats Labor has won, the Liberals are looking at a two-term strategy. The odds are on more than one leader, and generational change, in that time. Tim Wilson, 45, who has won back Goldstein, obviously has his eye on the prize in the longer term.

Despite all the disincentives, Sussan Ley, 63, and Angus Taylor, 58, both want this thankless post that’s up for grabs at Tuesday’s party meeting.

The battle has turned into a fight over negatives as much as positives. Supporters of Ley say Taylor did a dreadful job as shadow treasurer, including not producing a tax policy. The Taylor camp argues Ley, the deputy leader, under-performed generally.

Both contenders hold regional NSW electorates. Taylor’s support base is the conservative wing of the party; Leys’ is the moderate wing. The relative weightings of the factions in the Liberal party room has changed somewhat as a result of the election, in the favour of the moderates.

hadow Attorney General Michaelia Cash and Shadow Minister for Indigenous Australians Jacinta Nampijinpa Price at a campaign rally for volunteers in Mount Pleasant in Perth. Mick Tsikas/AAP

For those Liberal MPs whose votes are not tightly locked in by factional allegiances, there are multiple questions they need to consider.

Who will be able to keep the party together, while forcing it to face up to what changes it must make, and driving a major overhaul of policy? Who can improve the Liberals’ standing with women, and with younger voters? Who can better handle the relationship with the Nationals?

On the last point, anyone who might think it would be best to break the Coalition is, I believe, misguided. Going it alone didn’t work in the 1970s and the 1980s. Different as they may be, the Liberals and Nationals are, electorally, two parts of a whole.

They need their collective numbers to win and they’re better to stay together in opposition, to make the partnership in government work. But the relationship may be rocky.

At the election, the Nationals retained almost all their seats and will have a relatively bigger voice from now on.

On Thursday, however, their highest profile senator, Jacinta Nampijinpa Price, jumped from the Nationals to the Liberals. She said she thought she could be more effective in the Liberals, “especially as the party faces a significant rebuild […] I feel obliged to play a robust part in”.

This was a concerted move from the right, and will play into the leadership contest in an as-yet unclear way. With speculation that she might run as Taylor’s deputy, Price was asked on Sky on Thursday night if she would be willing to be drafted for a position. “I will not put any limitations on myself,” she said.

For the Liberals, there is absolutely no silver lining from this election. The Greens can take some comfort in the fact they’ve retained their numbers (11) in the Senate, with only a small fall in their Senate vote. On the projected results, the Greens are set to be the sole negotiators with the government in the Senate on legislation opposed by the Coalition.

Who will become leader is still an open question, with South Australian veteran Senator Sarah Hanson-Young, deputy leader Mehreen Faruqi, and the party’s Senate leader, Larissa Waters, mentioned. Whoever gets the post, the leadership will return to the Senate, where it always was until Bandt obtained the position in early 2020.

Post election, Anthony Albanese has continued his fierce pre-election attack on the Greens. “What I hope comes out of the new Senate is a bit of a recognition that one of the reasons why the Greens political party have had a bad outcome in the election is the view that they simply combined with the Coalition in what I termed the ‘noalition’, to provide blockages, and that occurred across a range of portfolios, housing, treasury, as well as environment,” he told the ABC.

Albanese was particularly scathing about Greens housing spokesman Max Chandler-Mather who lost his seat and criticised parliament as a “sick place”.

“Maybe what he needs is a mirror and a reflection on why he’s no longer in parliament. […] This is a guy who stood before signs at a CFMEU rally in Brisbane describing me as a Nazi.”

Bob Brown, the Greens’ inaugural leader from 2005 to 2012, describes Albanese’s comments as “ungracious” in “his moment of glory”.

Former Greens leader Bob Brown and Senator Sarah Hanson-Young are seen with protesters during a rally against a proposed Kangaroo Island private tourism development.

While the Greens’ pro-Palestinian position came under much criticism, Brown strongly defends it, declaring it “honorable”.

Brown, speaking to The Conversation, says the Greens will be in an extraordinarily powerful position in the Senate, and their “environmental origins will  come back to the fore”. He urges the Greens to “have deaf ears to calls for the Senate to be a rubber stamp”. The Constitution, he says, has the Senate with equal powers with the house except on money matters.

Brown predicts the Greens will be “resurgent” at the next election.  His strongest message is directed squarely at the government. “The Greens should never direct preferences to Labor again - because Labor takes preferences with one hand and stabs the Greens with the other.”

Like the new Liberal leader, Bandt’s successor will inherit a party at a fork in the road. Does it become more militant or more moderate, more confrontational in its dealing with the government, or as transactional as possible?

Bandt’s hope of the Greens power-sharing with a Labor government in the lower house has evaporated. So how does the party use what power it has in the Senate, while trying to put itself in the best position to avoid going further backwards at the next election?

Authors: Michelle Grattan, Professorial Fellow, University of Canberra

Read more https://theconversation.com/grattan-on-friday-bitter-struggle-in-liberals-for-likely-poisoned-chalice-as-jacinta-price-defects-from-nationals-255634

The Importance Of Structured Commercial Office Cleaning In Busy Office Environments

Office spaces are dynamic environments where people collaborate, meet clients, and spend a significant portion of their day. Maintaining cleanliness...

Single Tooth Dental Implant for Natural Tooth Replacement and Lasting Stability

Losing a single tooth can have a noticeable impact on comfort, appearance, and confidence, which is why a Single Tooth Dental Implant is considered...

When Grief Doesn’t Follow a Timeline

Grief rarely moves in a straight line. It doesn’t follow stages neatly, and it doesn’t respond well to pressure — especially the quiet pressure ...

Steel Plate And Its Role In Modern Construction And Manufacturing

A steel plate is one of those materials that quietly holds the modern world together. It does not demand attention, yet it supports bridges, buildin...

Understanding Fat Transfer to the Breast: What to Know Before Considering the Procedure

Surgical options for breast enhancement have evolved over time, offering different approaches depending on a person’s goals and body type. One opt...

What to Do When Your Car’s Side Window Is Broken

A shattered side window is more than an inconvenience. Whether caused by a break-in, road debris, or accidental impact, it leaves your vehicle exposed...

Shopify Web Development and Shopify Website Development for Scalable Online Stores

Choosing the right platform is a crucial decision for any online business, and Shopify web development has become a popular choice for brands that ...

How a Burleigh Heads Plumber Tests for Pipe Leaks

Pipe leaks can be deceptively difficult to spot. Some announce themselves with a steady drip under the sink, but many develop quietly behind walls, ...

What Local Businesses Should Expect from IT Services in Melbourne?

If you run a Melbourne business with roughly 7–100 staff, you have probably noticed something over the last couple of years. The IT problems got m...

How Professional Cleaning Improves Indoor Air Quality

Indoor air quality (IAQ) plays a crucial role in our health, comfort, and overall wellbeing. Australians spend nearly 90% of their time indoors-at hom...

Solar and Solar Battery Systems: Powering Smarter Homes in Victoria

As energy prices continue to rise and sustainability becomes a priority for Australian homeowners, more families are investing in Solar and Solar Ba...

Plumbing Emergency Melbourne: What to Do When Every Minute Counts

A sudden plumbing issue can quickly turn into a major disaster if not handled promptly. From burst pipes and overflowing toilets to leaking gas line...

Why Older Melbourne Homes Require Detailed Building & Pest Inspections

Older homes make up a large part of Melbourne’s housing stock. Victorian terraces, Edwardian houses, Californian bungalows, and post-war brick hom...

7 Essential Tips for Choosing Reliable Moving Services in Perth

Moving to a new home or office can be exciting, but it also comes with stress, planning, and plenty of decisions. One of the most important choices yo...

How to Find the Best Real Estate Agent Near You on the Central Coast

Choosing the right real estate agent can make a major difference to your final sale price, days on market, and overall experience. The Central Coast...

Unlock Durability And Beauty With Burnt Timber Cladding Solutions

Imagine a home or commercial space that not only stands the test of time but also tells a story through its very facade. In the world of architectur...

Offroad Caravans: Built for Adventure Beyond the Beaten Track

Australia’s vast and varied landscapes invite travellers to explore far beyond sealed roads and crowded parks. Offroad caravans are purpose-built ...

The Expert's Guide to Understanding Large Bore Steel Pipe Specifications

When it comes to infrastructure, construction, and various industrial applications, the choice of materials is paramount. Among the options availabl...