Modern Australian
The Times

As Donald Trump cuts funding to Antarctica, will the US be forced off the icy continent?

  • Written by Lynda Goldsworthy, Research Associate, Institute for Marine and Antarctic Studies, University of Tasmania
As Donald Trump cuts funding to Antarctica, will the US be forced off the icy continent?

President Donald Trump has begun eroding the United States presence in Antarctica by announcing deep funding cuts to his nation’s science and logistics on the icy continent.

The Trump administration has significantly reduced funding for both Antarctica’s largest research and logistics station, McMurdo, and the National Science Foundation which funds US research in Antarctica.

More cuts are foreshadowed. If carried through, US science and overall presence in Antarctica will be seriously diminished – at a time when China is significantly expanding its presence there.

Since 1958, the US has been a leader in both Antarctic diplomacy and science. Shrinking its Antarctic presence will diminish US capacity to influence the region’s future.

A black and white photo of two men standing between US and NZ flags.
The US has long been influential on the icy continent. Pictured: New Zealand explorer Sir Edmund Hillary, left, with US Lieutenant Commander David W Canham Jr in Antarctica on January 11 1957. AP

Why the US matters in Antarctica

The US has historically focused its Antarctic influence in three key areas:

1. Keeping Antarctica free from military conflict

The US has built considerable Antarctic geopolitical influence since the late 1950s. Under President Dwight D. Eisenhower, it initiated (and later hosted) negotiations that led to the development of the 1959 Antarctic Treaty.

It was also key to establishing the fundamental principles of the treaty, such as using the Antarctic region only for peaceful purposes, and prohibiting military activities and nuclear weapons testing.

A black and white photo of two men in suits, smiling.
President Dwight Eisenhower, left, poses with President-elect John F Kennedy in Washington on December 6 1960. Under Eisenhower, the US initiated the Antarctic Treaty. AP

2. Governing Antarctica together

The US was influential in developing the international legal system that governs human activities in the Antarctic region.

In the 1970s, expanding unregulated fishing in the Southern Ocean led to serious concerns about the effects on krill-eating species – especially the recovery of severely depleted whale populations.

The US joined other Antarctic Treaty nations to champion the Convention on the Conservation of Antarctic Marine Living Resources (CAMLR), signed in 1980. It prioritises conservation of Southern Ocean ecosystems and all species, over maximum fish harvesting.

The US also contributed to the 1991 Protocol on Environmental Protection. Among other measures it prohibits mining and designates Antarctica as “a natural reserve, devoted to peace and science”.

A man in a dark jacket watches as another man points at a map.
The US has been vital to Antarctic governance. Pictured: US Secretary of State John Kerry, right, at Scott Base in Antarctica in 2016. Mark Ralston/AP

3. Scientific research and collaboration

The US operates three year‑round Antarctic research stations: Palmer, Amundsen-Scott and McMurdo.

McMurdo is Antarctica’s largest research station. Amundsen-Scott is located at the South Pole, the geographic centre of Antarctica, and the point at which all Antarctic territorial claims meet. The South Pole station is thus important symbolically and strategically, as well as for science.

The US has the largest number of Antarctic scientists of any nation in the continent.

US scientific work has been at the forefront of understanding Antarctica’s role in the global climate system, and how climate change will shape the future of the planet. It has also played a major role in Southern Ocean ecosystem and fisheries research.

This research has underpinned important policies. For example, US input into models to predict and manage sustainable krill yields has been pivotal in regulating the krill fishery, and ensuring it doesn’t harm penguin, seal and whale populations.

The US has also been a staunch supporter of a comprehensive network of marine protected areas in the Southern Ocean. The Ross Sea Region Marine Protected Area proposed by the US and New Zealand is the largest in the world.

A ship near shore with a sign reading 'McMurdo Station'.
McMurdo is the largest research station in Antarctica. Wirestock Creators/Shutterstock

A broad ripple effect

The US influence in Antarctica extends beyond the list above. For example, the US has a significant Antarctic-based space program. And US citizens make up most Antarctic tourists, and the US plays a significant role in regulating tourism there.

The full extent of the Trump administration’s cuts is still to play out. But clearly, if they proceed as signalled, the cuts will be a major blow not to just US interests in Antarctica, but those of many other countries.

The US has the best-resourced logistics network in Antarctica. Its air transport, shipping and scientific field support has traditionally been shared by other countries. New Zealand, for instance, is closely tied with the US in resupply of food and fuel, and uses US air and sea logistics for many operations to the Ross Sea region.

And joint research programs with the US will be affected by reduced funding in Antarctica directly, and elsewhere.

For example, reported cuts to the climate programs of NASA and the National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration (NOAA) may hamper satellite coverage of the Antarctic and Southern Ocean. This would affect Australian scientists collecting data on ocean temperature, sea-ice state and other metrics used in climate research and weather forecasting.

People line up to board a plane marked 'US Air Force'.
People at New Zealand’s Christchurch Airport board a US Air Force plane as they prepare to fly to McMurdo Station in Antarctica. The US often shares its Antarctic logistics with other nations. Mark Baker/AP

Worrying times ahead

China has signalled its intention to be a key geopolitical player in Antarctica and has greatly expanded its Antarctic presence in recent years.

China has five Antarctic research stations. Its sixth summer station is due for completion in 2027. China also operates two icebreaker ships, helicopters and a fixed-wing aircraft in Antarctica and is building new, large krill trawlers.

Both China and Russia, are increasingly active in their opposition to environmental initiatives such as marine protected areas.

A smaller US presence creates greater opportunities for others to shape Antarctica’s geopolitics. This includes pressure to erode decades-long protection of the Antarctic environment, a push for more intensive fish and krill harvesting, and potentially reopening debate on mining in the region.

Lynda Goldsworthy and Tony Press co-authored the chapter Power at the Bottom of the World in the new book Antarctica and the Earth System.

A scene in Antarctica in pink and blue light.
A smaller US presence creates opportunities for others to shape Antarctica’s geopolitics. Oleksandr Matsibura/Shutterstock

Authors: Lynda Goldsworthy, Research Associate, Institute for Marine and Antarctic Studies, University of Tasmania

Read more https://theconversation.com/as-donald-trump-cuts-funding-to-antarctica-will-the-us-be-forced-off-the-icy-continent-254786

Diesel Shortage to Impact Trades and Contractors

Strait of Hormuz blockage affecting all major parts of trades and construction Trades and construction across residential, commercial and industria...

Why Holiday Home Owners Turn to Rental Management Agents

The Allure — and the Reality — of Renting Out Your Property Owning a holiday home is a dream for many Australians. Whether it's a beachside sha...

Why Finding Reliable Doctors In Bundoora Is Important For Long-Term Health

Access to quality healthcare plays an important role in maintaining overall wellbeing and managing health concerns early. Trusted Doctors in Bundoor...

Understanding the Different Types of Car Services: Minor vs Major

When it comes to car maintenance, one of the most important things every vehicle owner should understand is the difference between a minor and a maj...

How Superannuation and TPD Insurance Work Together

Superannuation is an essential part of financial planning in Australia. It is designed to provide individuals with income during retirement, helping...

Tiny Towns funding granted for Mt Hotham and Mt Buller upgrades

Alpine Resorts Victoria (ARV) has welcomed funding support from the Victorian Government’s  Tiny Towns Fund, with both Mt Hotham and Mt Buller se...

Locksmith Services: Why Professional Security Solutions Matter More Than Ever

Security is a critical concern for homeowners, businesses, and vehicle owners alike. Whether it involves protecting a property, replacing damaged lo...

Why Tooth Fillings Are Important For Protecting Damaged Teeth

Cavities and minor tooth damage are common dental problems that can worsen if left untreated. Professional tooth fillings help restore damaged teeth, ...

The Connection Between Visibility and Driver Confidence

Operating a vehicle safely requires an immediate, uncompromised stream of visual information from the surrounding road environment. A driver's decis...

Important Things To Know Before Starting An SMSF Setup

Planning for retirement requires careful financial decisions, and many Australians are now looking for more direct control over how their superannua...

Why Retail Cleaning Plays a Key Role in Customer Experience and Business Success

Professional retail cleaning services are an essential part of maintaining a welcoming, safe, and professional environment for customers and staff...

Simple Ways to Make a Commercial Property More Appealing to Buyers

Selling or leasing a commercial property isn’t just about listing the square metres, taking a few photos and waiting for the right person to appea...

What Café Owners Should Know Before Upgrading Their Display Setup

A café display fridge does a lot more than keep cakes cold and sandwiches fresh. It quietly shapes the way customers browse, the way staff move beh...

Creating a Backyard That Feels Comfortable All Year Round

A great backyard doesn’t need to be huge, expensive or perfectly styled. Most of the time, the spaces people actually use are the ones that feel e...

How Homeowners Can Make Smarter Energy Decisions Before Upgrading

Energy upgrades used to feel like something you only looked into after a power bill gave you a nasty surprise. These days, though, more homeowners a...

Why Retail CX Breaks During Peak Sales Events and How to Prevent It

Retail customer experience has become one of the most important drivers of revenue growth, especially during high-intensity sales periods. However, ev...

15 South Indian Dishes Everyone Should Try

If your only experience of "Indian food" is butter chicken and garlic naan, South Indian cuisine is going to feel like discovering an entirely new c...

What Every Homeowner Should Know About Roof and Drainage Maintenance

A home's roof and drainage system work together every day to protect the property from water damage. While many homeowners focus on visible areas such...