Modern Australian
Men's Weekly

.

Indigenous Australians are crucial to hitting our 2035 climate targets. That transition has to be fairer

  • Written by Duygu Yengin, Associate Professor of Economics; President, Economic Society of Australia (SA); Deputy Chair, Women in Economics Network, University of Adelaide

If we act now and move with common purpose, then we can do more than just guard against the very worst. We can protect our environment and build a stronger and fairer economy for the next generation.

That’s what Prime Minister Anthony Albanese told a special climate summit at the United Nations in New York on Wednesday, as he shared Australia’s new 2035 climate target with other world leaders.

And the prime minister is right: climate change isn’t just a threat. It’s also an opportunity to do things differently – and more fairly.

As our research shows, First Nations people and Indigenous-managed land will play a crucial part if we want to hit our 2035 targets. But energy justice and sovereignty need to be central in our climate policy.

Two key challenges stand out: reducing energy stress, which we found is a significantly bigger problem for Indigenous households today, and ensuring self-determination in renewable energy or critical mineral developments on Indigenous land.

Higher rates of energy stress

For too many Australians right now, power bills are rising, their homes are too hot or too cold, and decisions about big energy projects can be made without local voices being heard.

That’s certainly true for many Indigenous households and communities, right across Australia. For those in remote communities, they can face harsh weather, poorly insulated housing, and reliance on expensive diesel power.

Prepaid energy schemes – where you pay for power in advance and the meter cuts off when the credit runs out – are common in remote communities and drive up disconnections, leaving households especially vulnerable during extreme weather.

But energy stress isn’t confined to remote communities. For the 85% of Indigenous Australians living in urban and regional areas, energy stress often goes unnoticed.

Our recent research, using two decades of Household, Income and Labour Dynamics in Australia (HILDA) survey data and recent Energy Consumers Sentiment Survey data shows Indigenous households consistently struggle to consume the energy they need.

In 2023, more than 70% of Indigenous households reported energy stress — 15 points higher than non-Indigenous households.

Recovering from energy stress is hard. Our research shows that Indigenous households that had previously fallen behind on bill payments were 47 percentage points more likely to struggle again.

Having a rainy day fund of around A$4,000 can prevent a household falling behind. But Indigenous households often lack these reserves.

What’s the solution?

Unless we close the gap in energy stress, First Nations people will stay more exposed to the worst impacts of climate change. Looking overseas offers possible policy solutions.

In Europe, for example, seasonal disconnection bans and minimum supply guarantees can prevent energy loss during crises. Emergency credits and automatic vouchers further protect vulnerable families.

Canada goes even further for Indigenous households, offering targeted bill support, home upgrades and retrofits.

Canada also has a range of renewable energy and efficiency programs aimed at reducing dependence on diesel for heating and electricity.

Indigenous landholder sovereignty

But Indigenous Australians are not just energy consumers – they are landholders. And land matters.

Meeting Australia’s net zero targets won’t just happen anywhere. According to research by Net Zero Australia, almost half (43%) of new renewable energy infrastructure – from wind and solar to transmission and storage – will need to be built on recognised First Nations land to get to net zero emissions by 2060.

Almost 60% of critical energy minerals projects already sit on land where Indigenous peoples have a right to negotiate. With pending native title claims, that could jump to nearly 80%.

Indigenous peoples hold the keys to Australia’s net zero transition – so should share the benefits fairly.

Australia's Prime Minister Anthony Albanese speaks during a climate summit
Australian Prime Minister Anthony Albanese addressed a UN climate summit on Wednesday. Yuki Iwamura/AP

Fairer negotiations

In 2024, the federal government launched the First Nations Clean Energy Strategy, committing A$70 million to support Indigenous-led renewable initiatives. Its goals were: autonomy, self-determination, and meaningful participation.

Policy ambitions alone don’t guarantee results. Recent laws introduced in South Australia illustrate how legislation can clash with these aims.

South Australia’s Hydrogen and Renewable Energy Act 2023 introduced two major changes regarding negotiations over renewable projects.

First, it lets the government choose a single energy company to negotiate an agreement with native title holders.

Imagine a house auction where just one buyer was allowed to bid – would the homeowner ever get the best offer?

And second, if negotiations fail, the government can force a sale through compulsory acquisition. In our previous analogy, it’s as if the homeowner dislikes the bid but is forced to sell anyway, with the price set later by a judge.

And while intended to fast-track renewables, economic research shows both measures undermine Indigenous consent, bargaining power, compensation amounts and energy sovereignty.

Levelling the playing field

Even without these rules, the field is uneven. Developers bring a whole team of lawyers, valuers, and experts to the negotiations. Indigenous communities often face the game alone.

Though this Act applies in South Australia, similar federal powers exist, so the risks are national.

Economic analysis suggests four changes to improve fairness:

  1. let multiple renewable energy companies compete for agreements
  2. use compulsory acquisition only as a last resort, after competitive bidding and fair cultural and economic valuation
  3. make all price offers, compensation methods, and impact assessments transparent through a state-managed register
  4. fund Indigenous access to expert negotiators and lawyers.

Indigenous households and landholders must not just survive this energy shift — they must lead it, benefit from it and thrive.

Authors: Duygu Yengin, Associate Professor of Economics; President, Economic Society of Australia (SA); Deputy Chair, Women in Economics Network, University of Adelaide

Read more https://theconversation.com/indigenous-australians-are-crucial-to-hitting-our-2035-climate-targets-that-transition-has-to-be-fairer-265980

Full Mouth Rehabilitation: A Comprehensive Dental Solution for Patients Seeking Advanced Care Abroad

Dental health plays a vital role in overall well-being, confidence, and quality of life. For individuals experiencing extensive dental issues such a...

Fertility Treatment in Australia | Expert Reproductive Care

One of the most significant journeys in life is the formation or the development of a family. To most couples and individuals, conception, however, ...

Professional Bathroom Builders Sydney: What Defines Professional Standards

Professional bathroom builders in Sydney operate within a regulated construction environment that prioritises safety, compliance, and structural durab...

Retail Cleaning Creating Welcoming and Professional Store Environments

First impressions matter in retail, and cleanliness plays a powerful role in shaping how customers perceive a store. Retail cleaning focuses on mai...

Why Year 12 Tutoring Plays A Crucial Role In Academic Success

The final year of school is one of the most demanding periods in a student’s academic journey, which is why year 12 tutoring has become an essent...

Legal Remedies Available in a Breach of Contract Case

When a contract is broken, the consequences can affect cash flow, reputation and ongoing business relationships. A breach of contract may occur when...

Long Weekend Camping in the Yarra Ranges: Three Weekends of High Country Adventure

Yarra Ranges National Park, Victoria. Image by Mattinbgn (talk · contribs), CC BY 3.0, via Wikimedia CommonsVictoria’s Yarra Ranges offer keen trav...

Why Waste Management Solutions Are Essential For Modern Businesses

Managing waste responsibly has become a critical priority for organisations of all sizes, which is why waste management solutions play such an impo...

The Importance and Varieties of Ride-On Mower Tyres

Ride-on mowers are built to manage larger lawns with consistency and control. The quality and design of ride on mower tyres play a critical role in ...

Gain Peace Of Mind: The Undeniable Benefits Of A Ready First Aid Kit

Life in our vibrant communities, whether it's the bustling city or the quiet country town, is full of unexpected moments. From a scraped knee on the...

The Most Common Conveyor System Issues in Manufacturing

In modern manufacturing, conveyor systems play a central role in keeping production lines efficient, consistent, and cost-effective. When they operate...

How to Secure a Long-Term Rental in a Competitive Market

The rental market can be unpredictable and may present challenges if you’re not prepared. Initially, you might submit numerous applications and stil...

What Smart Investors Know About Real Estate

Many people think investing in property is just about buying a house and waiting for it to get expensive. While that can happen, the people who actual...

The Benefits of Seeking Help for Anxiety and Stress

Anxiety and stress have become common experiences in today’s fast-paced world, affecting people across all ages and lifestyles. From work pressures ...

How to Make the Most of Fashion Wholesale Options for Your Brand

If you want to grow a fashion brand without constantly reinventing the wheel, wholesale can be one of the smartest ways to scale. The key is knowing h...

How to Add Value to Your Home Before Selling

Selling a home is not just about putting up a sign and waiting for offers. It is about presenting a property that buyers instantly connect with and ar...

How Outdoor Play Enhances Learning and Wellbeing

You don’t need to be an expert to conclude that play is an essential part of growing up. When children aren’t restricted and kept indoors, they de...

How to Build Passive Income Through Real Estate

Building passive income is one of the most effective ways to create long-term financial security. While there are many investment opportunities availa...