Modern Australian

The government's bank reforms wouldn't have saved us a royal commission

  • Written by Clinton Free, Professor, UNSW
The government's bank reforms wouldn't have saved us a royal commission

In a bid to fend off the Financial Services Royal Commission, the government introduced the Banking Executives Accountability and Related Measures Act (BEAR) last October. This legislation comes into effect next week.

But it is questionable whether it would have prevented many of the excesses and scandals that the royal commission has unearthed. In choosing not to impose restrictions on variable remuneration (bonuses, commissions etc.), BEAR effectively left untouched the incentives for inappropriate financial advice and lending decisions.

Read more: Why the new banking laws won’t be the slam dunk the government is expecting

BEAR is explicitly intended “to improve the operating culture of [Authorised Deposit-Taking Institutions] and increase transparency and accountability across the banking sector”. To do this, the act imposes a range of obligations on ADIs (our banks, building societies and credit unions) and their subsidiaries.

There is a requirement to conduct business “with honesty and integrity, and with due skill, care and diligence”. There is also a requirement to cooperate with the regulator. This includes identifying the specific accountability of senior executives.

Perhaps the most interesting obligations under BEAR are those pertaining to remuneration. These mandate a minimum deferral of 40% of variable pay for four years and clawback provisions in cases of bad behaviour. In other words, executives can lose their bonuses for poor behaviour even years after the fact.

The BEAR Act represents the first major step towards regulation of executive remuneration in Australia.

Other countries, particularly the UK and in Europe, have substantially more expansive regulatory regimes. There are no rules in Australia capping bonuses as a ratio of salary (as there are in the Netherlands, UK and Germany, based on EU rules).

BEAR adds momentum to a growing current of banker surveillance, and its symbolic and rhetoric value should not be dismissed. However, there is little empirical evidence to suggest these rules will impact behaviours.

Research into white-collar crime suggests that in many cases offenders pay limited regard to potential sanctions in decision-making, let alone malus or clawback provisions for poor performance (which are nothing new for bankers). Short-term outcomes and incentives tend to be more salient than long-term risks, particularly in an environment not characterised by strong enforcement.

Moreover, by opting not to impose a cap on variable pay, BEAR is unlikely to impact misconduct fuelled by a heavy use of bonuses to reward financial outcomes.

Examples of this misconduct include the CBA Dollarmites scandal, inappropriate fee structures at AMP and even the payment of bribes at NAB.

Research shows that variable pay incentives are instrumental in the creation of a sales culture at the banks that privileges financial profits over customer welfare.

Deferral of these incentives, without acting on the scale and ratio of incentives to base salary, is unlikely to have a substantial impact.

More is required to ensure that remuneration policies actually address behaviours. A more fundamental question must also be considered: in light of the culture of misconduct exposed by the royal commission, is it even possible to regulate culture?

Authors: Clinton Free, Professor, UNSW

Read more http://theconversation.com/the-governments-bank-reforms-wouldnt-have-saved-us-a-royal-commission-98939

Sugar-Free Chocolate Treats: A Guilt-Free Indulgence

People are very conscious about their health and sugar-free chocolates are becoming a popular option. This is a delicious and very satisfying option...

The Most Scenic Sailing Destinations in Australia and New Zealand

Australia and New Zealand are home to some of the world’s most breathtaking sailing destinations. With vast coastlines, pristine waters, and diver...

How Portable Cool Rooms Can Enhance Event Catering: The Perfect Solution for Outdoor Events

If you are holding an event outdoors, then there should be quality food; otherwise, a well-planned outdoor event will not be successful. Because c...

Successful Launches Using White Label Crypto Exchange Software

The cryptocurrency market has witnessed exponential growth in recent years, prompting many entrepreneurs and businesses to enter the space. One of t...

Space and Design Optimization for a Bathroom Renovation in Melbourne

Bathroom re-designing in Melbourne might present a challenge when first considered but, with the right approach, it is definitely achievable. Aesthe...

Dogging Training in Adelaide: Essential Skills for Load Handling and Safety

Dogging training is among the essentials for professionals in Adelaide, who are in charge of the supervision of crane operations and safe slinging...

What Are the Rules for Keeping in Touch Days in Australia?

Returning to work after parental leave can feel like a big leap, but "keeping in touch days" are designed to ease that transition. In Australia, these...

Navigating the Geelong Building Design Process: From Concept to Completion

Geelong home design requires a lot of thinking right from the conception to the product. Think about the perfect home you are going to have, locat...

Quiet Nights and Peaceful Days: The Benefits of Noise-Reducing Double Glazing

Are you tired of the constant noise from traffic, barking dogs, or rowdy neighbors disrupting your peace? Imagine coming home to a quiet, peaceful s...

Top 10 Unique Party Themes for Adults: Creative Ideas for Memorable Celebrations

When it comes to adult birthday parties or milestone events, it’s time to think outside the box. Forget the ordinary and dive into unique, creativ...

Anniversary Gift Ideas: What to Give for Every Milestone Year

Celebrating anniversaries is a beautiful tradition that allows couples to reflect on their journey together and express love and appreciation. Wheth...

The Durability of 2HSL Floats: Why Investing in Quality Saves Money Long-Term

Well-assembled floats should assure long-term performance. A long-term saving might be from not having to replace or repair floats put into good u...

15 Top Restaurants in Wynnum Manly QLD

Brisbane’s bayside suburbs of Wynnum and Manly are home to a vibrant culinary scene, offering stunning water views, local charm, and delicious eats...

Importance of Gym Cleaning for Customer Satisfaction and Loyalty

A clean gym is essential for building customer satisfaction and loyalty. Members are more likely to return to a fresh and hygienic space.  Maintai...

5 Mistakes to Avoid When Choosing Affordable Electricity Providers

Selecting the right electricity provider can save you a lot of money on your energy bills. With so many cheap electricity providers to choose from...

Best Electrical Services Perth: What to Look For

To help find the best electrical services Perth, you should know what criteria to look for to get top-of-the-line service. When it comes to your h...

Commercial Construction Companies Melbourne: Building the Future of Urban Development

Melbourne has many highs, considering rocking and bigger skylines, and urban and industrial developments. The city is skyrocketing in buildings an...

Sydney Off Road Trips - Yes, They Exist

Are you ready for the adventure of a lifetime? When it comes to exploring in caravans, Sydney residents may not realise how easy it is to get away...