Modern Australian
The Times Real Estate

.

How Twitter got blindsided by India’s still-toxic caste system

  • Written by Hari Bapuji, Associate professor, University of Melbourne

Twitter chief Jack Dorsey’s first visit to India had been going so well. He got to meet Prime Minister Narendra Modi (an avid Tweeter with 44.5 million followers), “King of Bollywood” Shah Rukh Khan (36.8 million followers), and the Dalai Lama (18.8 million followers).

Then a single tweet had him being accused of hate mongering. There was talk of an Indian boycott of Twitter, and even of developing a rival Indian platform like China’s Weibo. A senior parliamentary official saw a case to prosecute Dorsey for attempting “to destabilise the nation”. A court in the northern state of Rajasthan ordered a police investigation.

Dorsey’s offence: holding a poster that proclaimed “Smash Brahminical Patriarchy”.

How Twitter got blindsided by India’s still-toxic caste system Twitter’s Jack Dorsey with the ‘Smash Brahminical Patriarchy’ poster that has him accused of hate-mongering.

The poster was given to Dorsey by Sanghapali Aruna, an activist for the rights of Dalits, the bottom most group in the Indian caste system. The controversy resulting demonstrates just how potent caste remains, and how blind to it are the multinational corporations eyeing off the Indian market.

A short guide to caste …

To understand what the fuss is about, we need to understand the age-old caste system in the Indian subcontinent, and its complexities.

Caste is similar to a social class, but mobility is impossible and discrimination can occur among those of the same economic class. It is similar to the idea of race, but can be perpetuated by those within the same ethnic group. It originated in Hinduism, but has been absorbed by Muslims, Christians and Sikhs.

Read more: Racial and caste oppression have many similarities

The system can be traced to the Manusmriti code of Hindu laws, which suggests Brahma, the Hindu god of creation, created four categories of people from his own body: Brahmins from his head, Kshatriyas from his arms, Vysyas from his thighs, and Shudras from his feet.

This origin ordained an occupational hierarchy. You inherited your caste from your father, and that determined your future. The Brahmins were the priests and advisers – and primary enforcers of the caste system. The Kshatriyas were warriors and soldiers. Then Vysyas farmers and traders. The Shudras workers and tradespeople.

Beneath the Shudras were the Dalits – the “untouchables” – tasked with all menial jobs, including cleaning and disposing of the dead.

How Twitter got blindsided by India’s still-toxic caste system Lower caste jobs include ‘manual scavenging’ – emptying certain types of dry toilet by hand. Though the practice was formally prohibited in India in 1993, it continues to occur. Donald Yip / Shutterstock.com

The system imposed codes of conduct and rules for interaction between castes. Mixed marriages, for example, were forbidden. So too was physical contact with all Dalits, who were condemned to live away from the village and had no right to public places, such as temples.

Although discrimination against Dalits was outlawed by India’s constitution in 1950, caste-based prejudices live on, and are even inflamed by Dalits asserting the right to equality.

Read more: Why are there so few Dalit entrepreneurs? The problem of India's casted capitalism

The constitution also enshrined affirmative-action programs for Dalits and other marginalised groups in the public sector, but across the Indian economy they continue to occupy the lowest rungs. Centuries of caste-based discrimination has enabled deep economic inequalities that still influence the opportunities and rewards given to individuals.

… and to patriarchy

Dalit women have the worst of it. They face discrimination from other castes, as well as from men within their own caste. They are more likely to be trafficked and subjected to contemporary slavery. They are still forced into temple prostitution known as Devdasi or Jogini systems.

Traditional ideas about gender roles still affect what is considered appropriate for women to do, what they can wear and who they can interact with. Women resisting such patriarchal notions can face reprisal, from abuse to violence, rape, and even murder.

Read more: India's caste system extends to uneven access to cooking fuel and electricity

The interrelationship between caste hierarchy and gender hierarchy in traditional Indian culture is known as the “Brahmanical social order”. That Aruna’s poster referred to “Brahminical patriarchy” has offended some as a more direct attack on Brahmins, not just the caste system. This may be reading too much into it. Others have reacted to the poster as an attack Hinduism. Yet others have been offended by a foreigner seemingly lecturing Indians on something he knows little about.

How Twitter got blindsided by India’s still-toxic caste system Women sort through piles of rubbish in Calcutta. JeremyRichards / Shutterstock.com

Twitter’s ecosystem challenge

It is into this landscape that Twitter’s chief lumbered.

India is Twitter’s most important developing market. Its population will soon overtake that of China, where the government blocks Twitter. Though the eight million Indians who actively use Twitter is still less than a quarter of the Americans who do, US user numbers have plateaued while the Indian market is growing at five times the global average.

Twitter is also arguably important to India. It has given Dalit women and other marginalised people a platform to voice their concerns. But it has also facilitated trolling and abuse. In mid-November Shehla Rashid, a student leader with more than 500,000 followers, quit the platform as an “SOS call to Twitter”. Describing the platform as an ecosystem of “toxicity and negativity”, she said: “It is not freedom of expression but an attack on freedom of expression.”

Listening, not hearing

This is the reason Dorsey met with Aruna and other women at the end of his India trip: to hear firsthand their concerns about the way Twitter facilitates abuse and threats.

Read more: The Dalits of India are finding new ways to fight the caste system

The company’s reaction to the aftermath would not have persuaded the women they had been heard. Twitter quickly declared Dorsey was merely holding the poster because he had been given it as a gift, and that the poster’s sentiments were not Twitter’s official position. Twitter’s chief legal advisor, Indian-born Vijaya Gadde, apologised for failing to be “an impartial platform for all”.

Such a response was “hypocritical”, declared journalist Sidharth Bhatia, because Twitter “apologised to those very people whom the poster was calling out, only because they are noisier and better organised”.

Multinational blind spots

How could Twitter be blindsided by caste?

One reason may be a problem shared by most multinational companies operating in India. They might promote gender and ethnic diversity in their home countries, but caste is less obvious to them. Unconsciously they might even be perpetuating the caste system.

When multinationals hire, they prefer people with a certain type of family background and cosmopolitan profile. Those from upper castes – beneficiaries of accumulated advantage over centuries – tend to fit that bill. As a result they are more likely to get hired and promoted to positions of power. Thus, the caste system is unconsciously replicated.

Multinationals – and indeed all companies in India interested in its future prosperity – need to think about the ways in which caste inequalities operate. They must work to improve caste diversity in their ranks, such as through including caste in audits and educating their workforce.

Twitter has an additional challenge. It needs to ensure its platform is not a tool of caste and other forms of discrimination. Taking responsibility and cleaning up trolling, bullying and harassment on its platform would be a major public service to Indian society – and to democratic conversations everywhere.

Authors: Hari Bapuji, Associate professor, University of Melbourne

Read more http://theconversation.com/how-twitter-got-blindsided-by-indias-still-toxic-caste-system-107792

Health Heroes: 5 Unique Careers in Health and Wellness

When we think of health and wellness careers, the first roles that often come to mind are doctors and nurses. However, the world of healthcare is fa...

Biz Collection Workwear: Premium Uniforms for Australian Professionals

In this modern era, the presentation of the team matters the most in the growth of companies. The professional appearance attracts clients’ attent...

Managed IT Services for Australian Retailers

Australian retailers are constantly being compelled to deliver flawless customer experiences with tight security measures. Managed IT services, or M...

What to Consider When Looking for Family Lawyers in Brisbane

Family law issues can be deeply personal and emotionally charged, making it important to choose the right family lawyers in Brisbane. Whether you're...

Construction and Surveying: The Foundation of Modern Infrastructure

Precision and accuracy are the name of the game in construction. Construction and surveying are crucial disciplines that most public members remain ...

Why the Demand for Tutors is Growing Across Australia

As the academic stakes rise each year, students across Australia are increasingly turning to tutors to maximise their chances of success. But why the ...

House Movers in Perth: Tips for a Successful Relocation

Moving houses can be exciting, but it can also be an overwhelming process. The mere anticipation of packing up your life and transporting it somewhe...

Why Rental Property Inspections Are Important for Tenants and Landlords

Regular property inspection is one of the key components of a smooth rental experience, benefitting both the tenant and the landlord.  Experts sugge...

Beer Label Design for New Breweries: Where to Start in 2025

Imagine a customer picking up your beer based purely on its striking label. In a crowded market full of craft brews and new brands, first impression...

Functional and Fashionable: The Rise of Ladies Workwear in Australia

A perfect change in the Australian workforce has been happening in recent days. Women are contributing a lot in the male-dominated workplaces. They ...

Concrete Trailer Pump for Sale: Your Ultimate Solution for Efficient Concrete Placement

In construction projects where efficiency, precision, and flexibility are paramount, concrete trailer pumps for sale stand out as an essential piece...

Exploring Different Types of Solar Panels: Monocrystalline, Polycrystalline, and Thin-Film

The demand for solar energy continues to grow as more Australians embrace sustainable energy solutions. A crucial step in transitioning to solar pow...

Common Mistakes in Food and Wine Pairing (And How to Avoid Them)

Pairing food and wine is often considered an art, but it doesn’t have to be intimidating. The right pairing can elevate a dining experience, while...

Wine Tasting 101: A Beginner’s Guide to Smelling, Swirling, and Sipping

Wine tasting is an art form that can seem daunting to beginners, but with a little knowledge and a lot of enthusiasm, anyone can master the basics. ...

How to Fix a Clogged Shower Drain: Tips for Homeowners

A clogged shower drain is a common household issue that can be both frustrating and inconvenient. Over time, hair, soap scum, and other debris can a...

Top Trends in Electric Recliner Sofas for 2024

Electric recliner sofas have taken center level in the world of furniture layout, combining consolation, comfort, and superior generation. As we pas...

Setting Up the Perfect Home Studio for Drummers

Creating the perfect home studio for drumming is a fulfilling project that goes beyond just having a space to practice. A well-designed studio can a...

Essential Guide to Surveying Services for Land and Construction

Surveying is indispensable in all land development, real estate transactions, and construction. The core of surveys, including metric geodetic and pre...