Modern Australian
The Times

Is it a surprise women aren't keen on investing when the stock market language is so male oriented?

  • Written by Jose Sanders, Professor of Narrative Communication, Radboud University
Is it a surprise women aren't keen on investing when the stock market language is so male oriented?

The language used to describe investing in the stock market is skewed towards masculinity. It is full of metaphors that come from domains traditionally associated with, occupied by, or deemed appropriate for men.

Examples are “beating” the market (war, combat, physical fight), “level playing field” (soccer), and “building” your portfolio (construction). This is the case for different languages and for both websites targeting beginning retail investors and stock market reporting in national and financial newspapers.

People use conceptual metaphors like this in their language, often without realising it, to make abstract concepts (such as financial events and objects) more “imagineable”. A conceptual metaphor is a word or combination of words taken from the concrete, physical world to describe a concept from an abstract world.

Read more: Targeting hidden roots of workplace harassment is key to fulfilling Oprah's promise to girls

Importantly, our use of these sorts of metaphors is not random; we borrow words from a limited number of familiar domains in the physical world. And this is indeed what we found for the language used in investing.

“Building” in building your portfolio is a metaphor for putting together elements for future safety and comfort. So in theory you could equally well use phrases such as “growing”, “cooking”, “sewing” or “weaving” your portfolio. These activities also involve an effort in putting together elements to make your future life safe and comfortable.

But we don’t, and in fact if you used “knitting” in a discussion or presentation about investing, it would probably make the audience smile, giggle or even laugh out loud. This illustrates that these metaphors are not neutral.

They make certain aspects salient, while hiding others. In investing, for instance, “beating” the market highlights the aspect of competition, not that of making a return in order to have sufficient retirement income. However, you can find some investors that pay no attention to others and trade within the stock market using one of the best investment app platforms available, solely in an effort to increase their financial standings.

Is it a surprise women aren't keen on investing when the stock market language is so male oriented?

Changing the language in the stock market to be less gendered could encourage women to participate more. Justin Lane/EPA

Research in marketing shows that words used to describe products and services may have a different impact on consumers depending on whether the they identify with the domain the word belongs to or is associated with.

One example is a study on Diet Coke, which showed it did not appeal to men. When Diet Coke was replaced by Coke Zero, men did buy it. Evidently, the word “diet” called to mind a world men did not feel comfortable with: fitting clothes, standing in front of the mirror. But “zero” did appeal to men: zero tolerance, all or nothing, quantitative rigour.

So it’s not surprising that women are discouraged by metaphors that bring to mind a world they are traditionally not associated with: war and combat, construction and heavy physical activity. The use of such metaphors is hardly likely to create positive affect among women; in fact it could even create negative affect.

Research in social psychology finds that positive feelings towards a concept or product leads to people perceiving lower risk and having higher expectations of returns, people are therefore more willing to invest and trade. In finance, evidence suggests that due to “home bias”, people invest way too much in what is locally, habitually or culturally close to them because it feels familiar.

Familiarity is influenced by imagery and metaphors are an example of this. If the metaphors of investing create a positive affect among men and a negative affect among women, it may trigger stock market participation and risk taking by men, not women.

This may, in part, explain the difference in stock market participation and financial risk taking by men and women. For example, in the Netherlands, still only one in seven investors is female.

This so-called gender gap in investing is often explained by lower levels of financial literacy and risk tolerance among women. However, this explanation is flawed in two respects.

There is little evidence for a beneficial effect of financial education on financial behaviour. Research also reveals that there is no biological difference in risk attitude of men and women.

Read more: Email culture to blame for workplace failure on #MeToo

Stressing the “need for creating financial awareness among women and girls” is therefore not only belittling to women, it also misses the point when it comes to explaining the gender difference in investment attitudes and behaviour.

If policymakers, regulators and the financial industry wish to reduce this difference, they could start by paying careful attention to their financial language use which reflects their traditionally gendered culture. Adapting and changing this language might not only contribute to lowering women’s psychological barriers when it comes to the stock market, it could also reduce the male tendency of trading excessively and taking on too much risk in the stock market.

Olga Leonhard, communication specialist at Framer Framed, contributed to this article.

Authors: Jose Sanders, Professor of Narrative Communication, Radboud University

Read more http://theconversation.com/is-it-a-surprise-women-arent-keen-on-investing-when-the-stock-market-language-is-so-male-oriented-93578

Why Dust Control Matters During Bathroom Demolition

People usually expect bathroom demolition to be noisy.  No one thinks of dust — but it turns up everywhere. Inside cupboards. On couches. Along...

Why Roller Shutters And Outdoor Blinds Are Popular For Modern Properties

Many homeowners and businesses now install roller shutters to improve security, privacy, insulation, and weather protection across residential and ...

Slushie Machine Hire for Events: What to Check Before Booking

There's a moment at every great event when guests stop what they're doing and just enjoy something. A slushie machine is often that moment. It draws p...

Why AS/NZS Certified Sunglasses Are Essential for Australian Kids

Australia has some of the highest UV radiation levels in the world. That's not a warning label exaggeration; it's a measurable, documented fact that s...

Why People Regain Weight After Weight Loss?

Losing weight is hard; keeping it off is harder; and regaining it after all that effort is something many people go through more than most realise. ...

10 Benefits of Having a Frozen Yoghurt Machine for Your Business

Frozen yoghurt is a commercially viable dessert option for a wide range of food service businesses due to its versatility, efficiency, and consisten...

Why Slurry Hose is Essential For High-Performance Material Transfer

Handling abrasive and dense materials efficiently requires specialised equipment, which is why a slurry hose is a critical component in industries ...

Why Coworking Spaces In Melbourne Are Transforming The Way Professionals Work

The modern workforce is evolving rapidly, with flexibility, collaboration, and efficiency becoming central to how people work, which is why a coworkin...

The Everyday Wear and Tear Most Warehouse Storage Systems Experience

The modern warehouse is a dynamic, high velocity environment where industrial storage structures are subjected to immense, continuous physical stres...

Why Pendant Lights Continue To Be A Popular Choice In Modern Interiors

Lighting has become an essential design element in modern homes, influencing both the appearance and functionality of interior spaces. Many homeowne...

How Whiteboard Supports Structured Communication In Work And Learning Environments

Clear communication and structured planning are essential in both professional and educational settings, which is why a whiteboard remains a practi...

How A Cardboard Box Manufacturer Supports Modern Packaging Needs

Packaging has become an essential part of modern business operations across retail, manufacturing, logistics, and e-commerce industries. Many busine...

How Pallet Racking Helps Businesses Improve Warehouse Operations

Efficient warehouse management depends on reliable storage systems that support organisation, safety, and productivity. Many businesses use pallet rac...

Why I/O Controller Is Essential For Efficient Industrial Automation Systems

Modern industrial systems rely heavily on automation and precise data exchange, which is why an I/O controller plays a critical role in ensuring sm...

Why Modern Traffic Management Systems Are Important For Safer Roads

Cities and industrial facilities increasingly rely on advanced Traffic Light System technology to improve road safety, traffic flow, and operationa...

How Structured eCommerce Web Design Influences Online Buying Behaviour

A strong online presence begins with effective eCommerce web design that prioritises both functionality and user experience. Businesses entering or...

What People Mean by “Alternative Doctor” And Why Expectations Around Care Are Changing

When people search for an “alternative doctor,” they’re usually looking for something specific, even if they haven’t fully defined it yet. I...

Why Does My Power Keep Tripping? Common Causes Explained by Electricians Sydney

The electrical system is the lifeblood of your home, powering everything from your phones to cooking utensils and more. But from time to time, your po...