Modern Australian
Men's Weekly

.

It's time to stop exposing people to the dangers of Facilitated Communication

  • Written by Bronwyn Hemsley, Professor of Speech Pathology, University of Technology Sydney
It's time to stop exposing people to the dangers of Facilitated Communication

Anna Stubblefield, an ex-Rutgers University Professor of Philosophy, was convicted in 2015 of the rape of an intellectually and physically disabled man after falsely obtaining his consent for sex via a technique known as Facilitated Communication (FC).

Stubblefield was originally sentenced for 12 years, but recently her conviction was overturned on appeal. After pleading guilty to reduced charges, Stubblefield was sentenced this month to time served, lifetime parole supervision and placement on a sex offender registry.

While this strange story might seem unique, it is just the latest that we know of in a long history of adverse events related to the use of FC.

Read more: We count what matters, and violence against people with disability matters

How is FC meant to work?

FC, also called supported typing, is a technique in which a person called a “facilitator” provides physical support to a person with a disability in an attempt to help them point to pictures, printed letters or words on an alphabet board or keyboard.

Typically, the “facilitator” holds or touches the person’s hand, arm, back, or other part of the person’s body during typing. This is supposedly “stabilising” support, meant to allow the person with a disability to use slight movements.

However, FC is pseudoscientific, and its use is unethical. Controlled tests of FC in research and in legal cases have shown that the facilitator is, even subconsciously, authoring the person’s message.

How did FC become widespread?

FC was initially a local phenomenon in Australia in the 1980s. It might have stayed that way, but Dr Douglas Biklen of Syracuse University embraced it, promoted it in the Harvard Educational Review, and created the “Facilitated Communication Institute” (recently re-named the Institute for Communication and Inclusion).

FC came to be vigorously promoted and presented at international Augmentative and Alternative Communication conferences.

A form of automatic writing, FC gives the false impression that the disabled person is doing the typing. Despite anecdotal reports that it works, a simple “blinded” picture naming test is all it takes to reveal the true author. In such a test, the facilitator is not aware of the answers to questions asked of the person with disability. Over 30 studies of this type have found no convincing evidence that messages delivered using FC are authored by the person with a disability.

Read more: Science debunks fad autism theories, but that doesn't dissuade believers

There are several other communication technologies and strategies now available to enable a person with a disability to get their message across. These technologies are called Augmentative and Alternative Communication and include a variety of switches that people can use if they have difficulty using their hands.

What harm can it do?

There’s a long history of harms relating to FC, and it makes the news for all the wrong reasons. US businesswoman Gigi Jordan was sentenced to 18 years in prison for the murder of her son with autism on the basis of a message delivered using FC.

Apart from FC being a clear violation of the disabled person’s communication rights, FC related criminal cases often involve family members being falsely accused of sexual abuse. Jose Cordero of Florida is the most recent innocent person known to be imprisoned as a result of false allegations of sexual abuse delivered via FC. His name can be added to a growing list that includes the Wheatons, Julian Wendrow, and Mark and Laura Storch. The Wendrows won more than US$6 million in law suits.

It’s not possible to know how many more people with disabilities who use FC are currently being abused sexually through falsely giving consent to sex, but we do know of one other case similar to Stubblefield’s. In Australia in 2014, Martina Susanne Schweiger, a disability support worker received a suspended jail sentence for indecent dealings with a person with an impairment, brought about as a result of the messages delivered by FC.

Five good reasons to ‘keep your hands off’ FC

  1. FC is not a valid form of communication. It gives only the illusion of communication and denies people with disabilities access to their human rights of autonomy, self-determination, and freedom of expression.

  2. FC can mask the true nature, identity, and character of the disabled person.

  3. FC is a pseudoscientific technique that comes with the risk of inflicting great harms on disabled people, family members, and teachers through false allegations of sexual abuse, false consent for sex, or other crimes. Several professional associations worldwide have warned against its use.

  4. FC can also harm the facilitator. The discovery that it is the facilitator who is doing the typing can be devastating and confusing. Like Stubblefield and Jordan, any facilitator could be imprisoned for acting upon wrongful decisions made on the basis of using FC.

  5. FC costs families of persons with disabilities valuable money and time and removes opportunities for them to access appropriate treatments that work, including Augmentative and Alternative Communication and Applied Behaviour Analysis.

A right to communicate

People with communication disability have a right to communicate using any means that enables their freedom of expression. They also have a right to freedom from abuse.

We live in a time of extraordinary technological advancements, where people like Stephen Hawking are able to independently control computers to communicate. It is unnecessary to use facilitator-dependent techniques that have no merit and that are genuinely considered junk science.

Read more: The technology that gave Stephen Hawking a voice should be accessible to all who need it

In order to counter the myths of FC, it’s important to that people with communication disability, parents, professionals and disability organisations have appropriate access to evidence-based interventions. Closing the significant service gaps for people with communication disability – who need access to appropriately trained professionals – might be part of the solution to avoiding the harms of FC and replacing FC with treatments that work.

Authors: Bronwyn Hemsley, Professor of Speech Pathology, University of Technology Sydney

Read more http://theconversation.com/its-time-to-stop-exposing-people-to-the-dangers-of-facilitated-communication-95942

Why Reliable Air Conditioning Services Are Essential for Year-Round Comfort

Melbourne’s climate is known for its unpredictable swings—from scorching summers to chilly winters. This variability makes it crucial for homes ...

Expert Plumbing Solutions in Perth: From Hot Water Systems to Leak Detection

Plumbing is one of those things we often take for granted—until something goes wrong. From stepping into an unexpectedly cold shower to discovering ...

Eco-smart Car Removal in Sydney: Practical Steps That Cut Waste and Return Value

Sydney’s ageing cars add up to a serious waste stream, and choosing the right removal service makes a measurable difference. Your decision sends m...

Measuring the Success of Your Bus Advertising Campaign

Bus ads turn everyday travel into high-reach media. They move through busy corridors, sit in traffic where people can read them, and keep working af...

Partner Visa Pathways: Onshore vs Offshore Applications Explained

Choosing between Australia’s onshore and offshore partner visa routes affects timing, travel, work rights and budget. This guide explains the stru...

Serving Styles Compared: Buffet, Grazing, or Plated for the Office

Choosing how to serve food at a work function shapes the pace of the event, how people mingle and how smoothly the agenda runs. The right format dep...

5 Essential Tips for Hiring Gold Coast Plumbers

Finding the best plumber on the Gold Coast can be as complex as navigating a network of pipes, requiring an expert who is capable, reliable, and s...

Hidden Costs of Moving You Need to Budget For (And How to Avoid Them)

Moving house ranks among life's most busy experiences, and discovering unexpected expenses along the way certainly doesn't help with stress levels. Wh...

Understanding Australian Building Regulations: What Every Mornington Builder Wants You to Know

If you live on the Mornington Peninsula, you likely already feel the risk of bushfires,hot, dry summers, nearby bushland, and epic wind events. That...

Top 5 Home Exercises Recommended by Chiropractors for Better Posture

In today’s world of endless screen time and back-to-back Zoom meetings, it’s no surprise that posture-related issues are on the rise. From achin...

Simple Home Exercises to Manage Chronic Pain and Improve Mobility

Living with chronic pain doesn’t have to mean a life of limitation. Many people struggling with persistent discomfort find themselves moving less...

Smart Renovation Tips for a Sleek, Low-Maintenance Interior

In a world where time is tight and stress is high, our homes should feel like a refuge not another to-do list. That’s why smart renovations are tr...

Stay Cool in Queensland: The Complete Guide to Choosing the Right Air Conditioner

Introduction Queensland’s warm, humid climate makes a reliable air conditioning system an essential part of daily life. Whether you’re creating a...

Proving Partner Visas with Lawyers and Solid Evidence

You’re ready to build a life with your partner in Australia but the visa process quickly turns something personal into something official. Suddenl...

The History and Philosophy Behind Osteopathic Medicine

Osteopathy is more than just a hands-on approach to relieving pain—it’s a holistic health philosophy with roots in history, science, and a deep ...

Common Bathroom Renovation Mistakes and How to Avoid Them

Renovating a bathroom can be one of the most rewarding home improvement projects, offering both enhanced functionality and a fresh aesthetic. Howeve...

5 Simple Home Modifications to Support Occupational Therapy Goals

Every year, thousands of Australians face mobility challenges, chronic pain, or sensory issues that make daily tasks difficult. Simple changes at ho...

The Cost of Converting a Shipping Container into a Liveable Space

Container conversions often require more planning and labour than expected Early costs include foundations, framing, and structural reinforceme...