Modern Australian
The Times Real Estate

.

Don't just blame the driver – there's more than one cause of fatal truck crashes

  • Written by Sharon Newnam, Senior Research Fellow, Monash University Accident Research Centre, Monash University
Don't just blame the driver – there's more than one cause of fatal truck crashesThere is evidence to suggest there is a ‘system’ of factors influencing truck crashes.AAP/Perry Duffin

Recent truck driver fatalities in New South Wales and a call for action by Toll managing director Michael Byrne have refocused attention on the safety of Australia’s road transport industry.

Truck crashes are often blamed on drivers. This point is well-illustrated in more than 400 investigations into serious crashes in Australia that largely focus on driver characteristics (like gender and age) and behaviour (like speed and fatigue). This is mirrored in other research: the primary focus of crash causation has been on identifying the role of unsafe driver behaviours, such as inappropriate speed, fatigue and drug use.

The problem with this approach is that it does not identify the full range of factors contributing to crashes, and limits our opportunity to learn from crashes and improve safety in the industry. So, a rethink in the approach to road freight transport safety is urgently required to reduce fatalities and injuries.


Further reading: Rethinking the causes of road trauma: society’s problems must share the blame


Why current approaches fall short

Major safety audits in the Australian truck industry have identified a large number of work system failures. For example, multiple organisational factors were identified as contributing to the fatal crash of a fuel tanker operated by Cootes Transport in 2009.

While truck rollovers often are blamed on individual drivers, cases such as this illustrate that road transport organisations play a significant role in such crashes.

Prevention efforts in the transport industry are also driver-focused. Fatigue management is a good example. The core of the laws for fatigue management requires that a driver must not drive a fatigue-regulated heavy vehicle on a road while impaired by fatigue. This implies that fatigue is primarily a problem with the driver, rather than a work system that encourages drivers to operate a vehicle while fatigued.

Research has documented clearly the strong incentives, driven by market pressures and pay schedules, for drivers to engage in dangerous driving behaviours. So, the industry, regulators and government are currently overlooking the causes of crashes in their prevention efforts.


Further reading: The ‘fatal five’ causes of road trauma: who’s in control?


Toward a systems thinking approach

A rethink in the approach to road freight transport safety requires a shift from the driver-focused approach to a systems-thinking approach.

A systems-thinking approach is underpinned by the idea that road freight transport crashes are caused by multiple, interacting factors within the system. Driver error is seen as the outcome of the interactions between these factors – and not as a cause of crashes.

To maintain control over safety, the decisions and actions of government, regulatory bodies and road freight transport management must be informed by accurate information on the actual working conditions and the interacting factors influencing driver behaviour.

Our study of the road freight transportation system drew on contemporary knowledge about crash causation in road transport more generally, and in other safety-critical domains. We examined 21 publicly available Australian coronial inquest reports into truck crashes between 2004 and 2014.

Our study found these reports clearly identified the role of government, regulatory bodies, road safety authorities, the supply chain, freight companies, and freight drivers in crash causation. However, their recommendations were predominantly focused on fixing isolated components in the system, such as the decision-making of drivers and speed.

A new approach to investigating truck crashes is urgently required to help shift the focus during crash investigations from driver behaviour onto the work system and beyond – to the supply chain, regulatory bodies, and government agencies.

We need to stop blaming and start reforming the transportation industry using a systems-thinking approach. To do this, we need to design the methods and tools to collect the right data so that prevention efforts target the right elements in the transportation system – not just the truck driver or other road users. This should include developing an Australia-wide freight crash reporting and analysis system that is underpinned by systems thinking.

This is the responsibility of all parties in the transportation system. The safety of road users matters, and the status quo of focusing on drivers alone is a hindrance to achieving safer roads.

Natassia Goode receives funding from the Australian Research Council and the State of Queensland through the Department of Science, Information Technology and Information, Advance Queensland Research Fellowship.

Sharon Newnam does not work for, consult, own shares in or receive funding from any company or organisation that would benefit from this article, and has disclosed no relevant affiliations beyond their academic appointment.

Authors: Sharon Newnam, Senior Research Fellow, Monash University Accident Research Centre, Monash University

Read more http://theconversation.com/dont-just-blame-the-driver-theres-more-than-one-cause-of-fatal-truck-crashes-90388

Rope Rescue Training Explained: Techniques, Tools & Skills

Rope rescue training is critical for emergency responders, industrial workers, and anyone who operates in high-risk environments. Whether you're a fir...

The Different Career Paths in a Law Firm: From Clerk to Partner

The legal profession offers a structured yet diverse career path, with opportunities ranging from entry-level positions to esteemed leadership roles...

The Importance of Exercise for People with Disabilities: Adaptive Workouts

Exercise is a fundamental part of maintaining physical and mental wellbeing, and this holds true for people of all abilities. For individuals with d...

Planning a Construction or Renovation? Don’t Overlook the Plumbing!

Building or renovating your home is an exciting journey—designing layouts, selecting finishes, and watching your space come to life. However, while ...

Bathroom Tiling: Trends, Materials and Installation Tips

The world of bathroom tiling has come a long way, with new trends, improved materials, and innovative installation techniques, making it easier than...

Best Products to Increase Hair Density: What Really Works?

Do you want thick, voluminous hair? We get you!! There’s just something about a full head of hair that makes you feel more confident. But what do...

The Cost of Back to Base Security in Sydney: Is It Worth the Investment?

Sydney is a fantastic place to live. The beaches, the cafes, the culture. There’s a reason people are willing to pay premium prices for a spot in ...

Australian Workplace Engagement Declines Amidst Shifting Employee Priorities

Global leader in employee engagement and HR technology, Reward Gateway, has today released its second annual Workplace Engagement Index. The report...

The Right Mix: 5 Tips for Choosing Products Your Customers Will Love

Photo: Marcella Marcella / Unsplash Crafting the perfect product offering is difficult. You need to strike a delicate balance between building a busi...

Septic Tank Pump Out Cost: What to Expect in 2025

The size of the tank, the location and the rates charged by the service provider all affect how much a septic tank pump out will cost. Every thre...

How Machine Learning is Personalizing Orthodontic Treatment

Orthodontic treatment has seen a significant transformation over the past few decades, largely due to advancements in digital dentistry and artificial...

From Backend Logic to Frontend Magic: Merging Software Development and Web Design

Software design and web development go hand in hand in today's computer age. Backend logic is used for functionality, and frontend design makes soft...

Australians who want to buy their first home need concrete saving stratagems for their deposit

Many Australians aspire to own a house but face significant obstacles while trying to save for the necessary deposit. Given the increase in property...

Key Factors to Consider When Choosing the Right Professional Indemnity Policy for Your Business

"Unlock the secrets to choosing the ideal Professional Indemnity Policy for your business. Understand the critical considerations!" A Professional ...

Skills in Demand (Subclass 482): The Employer-Sponsored Work Visa for Skilled Professionals

Businesses in today's globalized economy are always looking for qualified individuals to fill important positions. Employers in Australia can fill ...

Recent Study Reveals Which Psychological Problems Affect Different Age Groups

In recent years, the wider community has started talking more about mental health, and for good reason. In Australia alone, 42.9% of people between ...

The Ultimate Guide to Flyscreen Windows: How to Keep Your Home Bug-Free in Style

Keeping your home free from insects doesn't mean sacrificing style or comfort. Flyscreen windows offer an effective solution to maintain a bug-free ...

Dating after separation - the do's and don't's

After a romantic split you move forward with plans for fresh dating relationships. The present moment brings excited feelings since you look toward ...