Modern Australian
The Times Real Estate

.

foreign donations and political influence

  • Written by Simon Chapple, Director, Institute for Governance and Policy Studies, Victoria University of Wellington

New Zealand’s opposition National Party is embroiled in a rolling controversy that erupted last week when former National MP and senior whip Jami-Lee Ross accused his leader Simon Bridges of corruption. Bridges has vehemently denied these accusations, and the evidence released does not support any allegations of illegality.

One dimension of the controversy that has attracted less attention is the connected issues of political party donations and foreign influence on New Zealand’s democratic system.

Read more: New Zealand's Pacific reset: strategic anxieties about rising China

Foreign influence

The discussion of foreign influence in New Zealand politics plays out mostly in terms of the activities of the People’s Republic of China. The local debate was initiated by Professor Anne-Marie Brady’s “Magic weapons” paper last year. Despite her warnings that China’s foreign influence activities have the potential to undermine the sovereignty and integrity of the political system of targeted states, the dominant view among New Zealand’s main political parties might best be described as “nothing to see here, time to move on”.

Reactions in New Zealand contrast sharply with the situation in Australia, where there has been a much more open democratic debate on the issue of China’s influence, as well as law reform designed to mitigate foreign interference.

Read more: Soft power goes hard: China's economic interest in the Pacific comes with strings attached

foreign donations and political influence Former New Zealand National Party member Jami-Lee Ross speaking to media. Boris Jancic, CC BY-ND

Last week, Jami-Lee Ross released a recording of a conversation he had with opposition leader Simon Bridges in June (full transcript). The transcript alleges that Zhang Yikun, a wealthy Chinese immigrant and a former member of the People’s Liberation Army with ongoing links to the Chinese state, made a donation to the National Party of $100,000. The conversation then turned to new candidates for the National party list, and the possible candidature of Colin Zheng, manager of a construction company owned by Zhang.

Keeping track of political donations

At a national level, there are rules under the Electoral Act 1993 regarding political donations to both candidates and to political parties. For candidates, a donor’s name and address must be reported for donations of more than $1,500. For party donations, the name and address of the donor must be reported where donations exceed $15,000.

For both candidates and parties, foreign donations (defined as from people who are not citizens or residents on the electoral roll or from incorporated or unincorporated bodies outside New Zealand) exceeding $1,500 are forbidden. Each registered political party must file an annual return of party donations with the Electoral Commission, which are then made public. In terms of party donations which hit a $30,000 threshold, a return must be filed within ten working days, as opposed to annually.

There are also restrictions on how much can be spent during a general election period, which also effectively constrain donations. Political party spending is capped at just over $1.1 million, plus $26,200 per electorate contested, for a total election spend of just under $2.7 million if all 60 electorates are contested.

Spending limits also apply to persons or groups who are not contesting the election directly but seek influence. They can spend up to $12,600 on election advertising during the regulated period without having to register with the Electoral Commission. A person or group whose spending exceeds that amount must register and they can spend a maximum of $315,000 on election advertisements.

Who raises what from whom

In 2017, National raised $4.6 million in party donations, vastly exceeding Labour’s $1.6 million, as well as busting the limits of what they could spend in that year’s election. $3.5 million of the National’s donations (76%) were anonymous under the $15,000 threshold, compared with 0.7 million of Labour’s (44%). The Green Party raised $0.8 million, with 72% under the disclosure threshold, and New Zealand First raised $0.5 million, with 84% under the threshold.

There is no requirement for political parties to report the amounts of overseas donations under $1,500. Consequently the public does not know how many foreign donations come in under that amount.

It would be easy for a foreign state to funnel money into a political party from a large number of foreign donors, all under the $1,500 threshold. Equally, if that state had access to local actors, it could funnel money into the system at amounts above or below the $15,000 threshold.

What donors get for their donations is unclear. At its least malign, donors seek to passively promote a political ideology which they consider to be beneficial. Where donations are part of developing a long-term quid pro quo relationship along multiple dimensions, donors’ and receivers’ motivations and exactly what is traded is very difficult to pin down from the outside.

Transparency International reports that New Zealand political parties are one of the weakest pillars supporting local transparency and good governance. Within this weak pillar, one of the weakest strands involves political finance and donations.

They argue that with the demise of mass political participation, parties are increasingly dependent on donations to function. This weakness means that local politicians are more likely to seek to “supply” influence, or at least dangle the prospect of influence, in front of wealthy bidders.

The “demand” to buy political influence has also risen. With the increase in worldwide inequality and kleptocracy, there are more rich people for whom buying influence is the norm. Specifically in New Zealand, there has been an influx of wealthy expatriates from China, where buying influence is an accepted practice. They often retain close links to the Chinese Communist Party, which runs an authoritarian, anti-democratic and oppressive regime. It is thus not surprising that issues of donations and foreign influence are increasingly entering into domestic political debates.

Authors: Simon Chapple, Director, Institute for Governance and Policy Studies, Victoria University of Wellington

Read more http://theconversation.com/new-zealand-politics-foreign-donations-and-political-influence-105489

Dating after separation - the do's and don't's

After a romantic split you move forward with plans for fresh dating relationships. The present moment brings excited feelings since you look toward ...

What to Look for in a Reliable Junk Removal Service

Choosing the right junk removal service can feel overwhelming, especially with so many options available. Every year, households and businesses genera...

The Benefits of Choosing Wholesale Packaging Supplies for Your Business

Quality packaging not only protects the product but also plays a key role in your branding, customer satisfaction, and cost management. One of the b...

Freight Shipping a Motorcycle: Avoid These Common Mistakes

Image by Ultimatetransport123 Shipping a motorcycle can be a relatively simple and smooth process. However, even the smallest error can result in d...

Large Bore Steel Pipes: Applications and Advantages in Industrial Projects

As the name implies, large bore steel pipes are massive, powerful tubes. By massive, we’re referring to their large diameters which typically star...

The Business Case for Installing EV Chargers at Service Stations: ROI and Future Trends

As Australia transitions to a net-zero future, the electric vehicle (EV) market is rapidly gathering momentum. With EV ownership in the country fo...

Wealth Without Boundaries: 5 Location-Independent Income Strategies

Photo: Mesut Kaya / Unsplash Many people dream of working from pristine beaches in Thailand, cosy cabins in the Alps, or the best coworking spaces Me...

High Visibility Work Shirts: A Must-Have for Workplace Safety

Workplace safety is a necessity. Workers from construction sites to manufacturing units should be visible for their well-being and they have it by w...

How to Prepare for Your Wedding Video Shoot: A Step-by-Step Guide

Your wedding video captures one of the most important days of your life, preserving precious memories and moments for years to come. To ensure the d...

Preparing for Debt Collection Amidst Economic Downturn in Australia

Economic downturns bring financial uncertainty, especially for Australian businesses reliant on consistent cash flow. The challenges multiply when c...

How to Enhance the Security of Your E-Commerce Site

In the digital age, e-commerce has become a vital part of the global economy, allowing businesses to reach customers far and wide. However, with thi...

Understanding Disability Service Providers: Roles and Responsibilities

Disability service providers are people who support individuals with disabilities. Their role is pretty simple: help people live their lives more in...

Top 10 Guest Posting and Content Agencies in Massachusetts for 2025

Digital marketing relies on SEO content creation and guest posting to get more people to see your website, increase search engine rankings, and establ...

Same Day Rubbish Removal: Convenience and Efficiency at Your Doorstep

In today’s fast-paced world, convenience is king. From on-demand food delivery to next-day shipping, modern living is all about getting what you n...

Optimising Workforce Efficiency: The Benefits and Implementation of Employee Scheduling Software

"Master workforce management with our guide on Employee Scheduling Software. Streamline tasks & increase efficiency seamlessly!" Employee sched...

Enhancing Road Safety with Technology and Apps

Road safety has always been a critical concern for individuals, organisations, and governments alike. With the rapid advancements in technology, a n...

Best Cleaning Methods and Tools for Solar Panels

Solar panels are a fantastic way to harness renewable energy, but keeping them clean is essential to maximise their efficiency. Dust, grime, bird dr...

The Benefits of Implementing a Uniform Policy

A well-thought-out uniform policy can be a game-changer for organisations of all types. Whether you run a corporate office, a retail store, or a tra...